Official: 2009 Fantasy Football Thread (Week 5)

[dead in 09]

Originally Posted by bright nikes

Why are you still holding onto McFadden?

Originally Posted by bright nikes

Need some help fellas:

1 WR:
Lee Evans vs Cle
Massaquoi @ Buf

1 RB:
C. Williams @ Phi
Julius Jones vs Jax

1 D:
Barret Ruud @ Phi
Elvis Dumervil vs NE

massaqoui, williams, dumervil

 

[Los Angeles]

Originally Posted by YuraS718

If your referring to me.. Why not? He's out a couple of weeks.. Not like there's much left on our FA

You can drop him right now and no one won't even touch him if he's healthy.

You're better off picking up Justin Fargas or Michael Bush.

Fred Taylor is also getting surgery, it might be slim pickings in the FA wire but keeping 2 useless duds ain't gonna do much for ya if they cant perform.

 

[thezephyr777]

Whos better Jackson or Chris Johnson

 

[scuse7]

Need trade help

My team

Rodgers
Steven Jackson
Lynch
Wayne
Sims-Walker
Housh
Celek

Bench- Flacco

I give Wayne Jackson Housh for MJD Colston Braylon?

I give Sims Walker Jackson Flacco for Chris Johnson Berrian and Warner

 

[yuras718]

Originally Posted by bright nikes

Originally Posted by YuraS718

If your referring to me.. Why not? He's out a couple of weeks.. Not like there's much left on our FA

You can drop him right now and no one won't even touch him if he's healthy.

You're better off picking up Justin Fargas or Michael Bush.

Fred Taylor is also getting surgery, it might be slim pickings in the FA wire but keeping 2 useless duds ain't gonna do much for ya if they cant perform.

Just dropped taylor for sammy morris. I don't know what kind of leauge your in, but our league people look at the big picture. 2-3 weeks isnothing when you have 6 bench spots, especially when theres no need to drop him or no1 better on the wire. Bush was already picked up. No sense in droppingsome1 who's not ready to play this week unless you absolutely have too.

 

[IATT]

Originally Posted by itsaboutthattime

who should i start at QB:

mcnabb vs. tampa (easy choice, but he is just coming back)

matt ryan vs. 49ers (coming off of a bye and you can throw on the 49ers)



pick 1 flex:

brandon marshall vs. pats

dwayne bowe vs. cowboys

donald brown vs. titans

chris cooley vs. panthers



and 1 D/ST

cards D vs texans

Pats D vs broncos

anyone?

 

[sensaciondelbloque]

BRITT vs COLTS or MANNINGHAM vs RAIDERS????? thanx in advance

 

[Los Angeles]

Both a toss up IMO.

Nmandi should be on Smith, but Manningham's production has fallen off.

 

[yuras718]

Originally Posted by bright nikes

Both a toss up IMO.

Nmandi should be on Smith, but Manningham's production has fallen off.

I'm afraid to play Manningham this week. I have him on the bench on both my teams this week. He had a horrible week last week with 3 droppedpasses, and their trying to get Hicks more of a role. I would rather wait to see what goes on this week for me to play him again.

 

[sensaciondelbloque]

Originally Posted by YuraS718

Originally Posted by bright nikes

Both a toss up IMO.

Nmandi should be on Smith, but Manningham's production has fallen off.

I'm afraid to play Manningham this week. I have him on the bench on both my teams this week. He had a horrible week last week with 3 dropped passes, and their trying to get Hicks more of a role. I would rather wait to see what goes on this week for me to play him again.

so is BRITT a solid pick or should just go with MANNINGHAM against a horrible OAKLAND team?

 

[scuse7]

I'd go with Manningham

 

[ou imran]

I need to start two out of

Coffee, Glen RB SF vs. ATL

Mendenhall, Rashard RB PIT @ DET

Hightower, Tim RB ARI vs. HOU

Lynch, Marshawn RB BUF vs. CLE

Portis, Clinton RB WAS @ CAR


Right now I leaning towards Coffee and Mendenhall and even though Portis has struggled Carolina has the worst rush D, and the other two have favorable matchups

 

[hwburnz]

I'd go with Coffee and Mendenhall as well.

Pick 3:

SJax vs. MIN
S. Slaton @ ARI
R. Rice vs. CIN
Coffee vs. ATL
T. Jones @ MIA.

I'm having a hard time benching SJax but I just don't see him doing much against MIN.

 

[johnson1]

Originally Posted by OU Imran

I need to start two out of

Coffee, Glen RB SF vs. ATL

Mendenhall, Rashard RB PIT @ DET

Hightower, Tim RB ARI vs. HOU

Lynch, Marshawn RB BUF vs. CLE

Portis, Clinton RB WAS @ CAR


Right now I leaning towards Coffee and Mendenhall and even though Portis has struggled Carolina has the worst rush D, and the other two have favorable matchups

Hightower and Mendenhall. Mendenhall comin off a huge week, Hightower off a bye week against a weak D

 

[scuse7]

Originally Posted by Johnson1

Originally Posted by OU Imran

I need to start two out of

Coffee, Glen RB SF vs. ATL

Mendenhall, Rashard RB PIT @ DET

Hightower, Tim RB ARI vs. HOU

Lynch, Marshawn RB BUF vs. CLE

Portis, Clinton RB WAS @ CAR


Right now I leaning towards Coffee and Mendenhall and even though Portis has struggled Carolina has the worst rush D, and the other two have favorable matchups

Hightower and Mendenhall. Mendenhall comin off a huge week, Hightower off a bye week against a weak D

Give Coffee Mendenhall Lynch

No way I take the bum hightower, EVER.

And nobody in my league wants +@!%%%@ Steven Jackson. Im getting shut down on everything. I think I'll have to settle on Deangelo Williams.

 

[jordan201]

Which deal shoud I do? I can do all of them if its right.

I give:
Vernon Davis

I get :
Percy

My other TE is Gonzo.

I give:
Shuab

I get:
Thomas Jones
Hines Ward

My other QB is Peyton.

I give :
Bowe

I get:
Lynch or Benson or Westbrook

 

[suge510212]

Cedric Benson (Proj 4) @ BAL. #1 Rushing D.

OR

Fred Jackson (Proj 9) @ CLE. Weak Rushing D, but Lynch in his second week back.

Who starts?

 

[Los Angeles]

Originally Posted by JoRDaN201

Which deal shoud I do? I can do all of them if its right.

I give:
Vernon Davis

I get :
Percy

My other TE is Gonzo.

I give:
Shuab

I get:
Thomas Jones
Hines Ward

My other QB is Peyton.

I give :
Bowe

I get:
Lynch or Benson or Westbrook

Do that Percy deal now.

I'd keep Schaub.

 

[certifiedsw]

Originally Posted by JoRDaN201

Which deal shoud I do? I can do all of them if its right.

I give:
Vernon Davis

I get :
Percy

My other TE is Gonzo.

I give:
Shuab

I get:
Thomas Jones
Hines Ward

My other QB is Peyton.

I give :
Bowe

I get:
Lynch or Benson or Westbrook

Damn, all those trades sound like a big W for you so I would do them all.

Originally Posted by SUGE510212

Cedric Benson (Proj 4) @ BAL. #1 Rushing D.

OR

Fred Jackson (Proj 9) @ CLE. Weak Rushing D, but Lynch in his second week back.

Who starts?

Start Fred Jackson, baltimore run d is just too good

For me though... who do I start:

First, Brent Celek vs. TB or Chris Cooley vs. Car?

Second, pick three out of these:

Santana Moss vs. Car
Welker vs. Den
Glen Coffee vs. Atl
Tashard Choice vs. KC
Jo Addai vs. Ten

 

[jordan201]

I wanna keep shuab too but it makes no sense since I have peyton.

And who should I take. Westbrook, Lynch, or Benson?

 

[certifiedsw]

Take Benson.

 

[suge510212]

Originally Posted by CertifiedSW

Originally Posted by JoRDaN201

Which deal shoud I do? I can do all of them if its right.

I give:
Vernon Davis

I get :
Percy

My other TE is Gonzo.

I give:
Shuab

I get:
Thomas Jones
Hines Ward

My other QB is Peyton.

I give :
Bowe

I get:
Lynch or Benson or Westbrook

Damn, all those trades sound like a big W for you so I would do them all.

Originally Posted by SUGE510212

Cedric Benson (Proj 4) @ BAL. #1 Rushing D.

OR

Fred Jackson (Proj 9) @ CLE. Weak Rushing D, but Lynch in his second week back.

Who starts?

Start Fred Jackson, baltimore run d is just too good

For me though... who do I start:

First, Brent Celek vs. TB or Chris Cooley vs. Car?

Second, pick three out of these:

Santana Moss vs. Car
Welker vs. Den
Glen Coffee vs. Atl
Tashard Choice vs. KC
Jo Addai vs. Ten

1) Celek: Will get his yards and will most likely catch one touchdown. Plus TB passing D is top 20 while Carolina's passing D is top 10.

2) Addai ( will get at least 10 pts), Moss (Campbell's fav), Choice (doing well as of late)

 

[certifiedsw]

Oh yeah... forgot to mention I'm in a ppr league

 

[IATT]

Originally Posted by itsaboutthattime

Originally Posted by itsaboutthattime

who should i start at QB:

mcnabb vs. tampa (easy choice, but he is just coming back)

matt ryan vs. 49ers (coming off of a bye and you can throw on the 49ers)



pick 1 flex:

brandon marshall vs. pats

dwayne bowe vs. cowboys

donald brown vs. titans

chris cooley vs. panthers



and 1 D/ST

cards D vs texans

Pats D vs broncos

anyone?

?

 

[certifiedsw]

Originally Posted by itsaboutthattime

Originally Posted by itsaboutthattime

Originally Posted by itsaboutthattime

who should i start at QB:

mcnabb vs. tampa (easy choice, but he is just coming back)

matt ryan vs. 49ers (coming off of a bye and you can throw on the 49ers)



pick 1 flex:

brandon marshall vs. pats

dwayne bowe vs. cowboys

donald brown vs. titans

chris cooley vs. panthers



and 1 D/ST

cards D vs texans

Pats D vs broncos

anyone?

?

Hmm... tough one at qb. I would go with Ryan, I would assume that the eagles are gonna run the ball more and don't wanna run the risk ofmcnabb getting hurt again. Flex start Marshall. And your defenses are

if I had to choose one though it would probably be the pats.