Man never wanted to be in the big lights
I don't think it's fair to say that he never did, because we literally have no proof.
The following is entirely possible and plausible:
When they had him, Pujols, & Sho, he thought they would accomplish big things. He played big, things crumbled, his body starting feeling the effects, so he was like, "I'll just re-sign here."
There's a monumental difference between "I really don't want big lights," and "I had hopes for big lights and they never happened and I'm okay with that."
Can’t blame anyone but Trout. If he wanted to leave he woulda been gone. He chose to stay and knew what came with it.
Absolutely.
You don't know how a team is going to be moving forward when you're signing a rookie contract.
Then the next time he re-signed, maybe he thought that being in the playoffs and being a contender was possible.
I don't know how many times he has extended or re-signed or whatever, but whatever his last contract was, he knew how unserious that franchise was at that point, no question.