- 27,294
- 15,000
3 Stacks is my dude, but him being from NY wouldn't change anything. He's definitely top 10 in my eyes, but Young Hov got that #1 spot.
Fact or Fiction: If Andre 3000 was from New York, he would be considered the GOAT hands down
- 22,895
- 26,768
IMO he's Overated already how do you make an all time top 5 when your whole career has been based off group work andddddddd since love below you get about 2 verses a year. Imagine the flack and pure hatred Hov would get if he did that
- 10,455
- 40
Originally Posted by Cole World 22
Andre 3k being from New York wouldn't eliminate Jay-Z, Biggie, Nas, Cole Eminem, etc. from having ever existed.
Will it boost his stock? Probably.
GOAT?
- 4,636
- 23
Originally Posted by Cole World 22
Andre 3k being from New York wouldn't eliminate Jay-Z, Biggie, Nas, Cole, Eminem, etc. from having ever existed.
Will it boost his stock? Probably.
GOAT?
- 385
- 10
I must of missed the joke.
The sad thing is that you guys really believe that me saying Cole is top 5 is more outlandish than y'all saying Kanye is top 25.
We're talking about RAPPERS, not Pop.
The sad thing is that you guys really believe that me saying Cole is top 5 is more outlandish than y'all saying Kanye is top 25.
We're talking about RAPPERS, not Pop.
- 823
- 15
J Cole is top 5 all time bro?
- 9,951
- 7,147
This Andre is GOAT stuff needs to stop. Son has a verse every three years and then goes back into obscurity. Let's let his solo album drop before we even say he's top 5 today. He doesn't have enough out IMO to be considered relevant and he's certainly not he greatest ever.
b smooth 202
Banned
- 10,295
- 106
says who?
when it comes to overall artistry we know guys like 3k and Ye are on another level than these rap #%!%!#...
no rapper could ever make a CD close to The Love Below...that %!+% is pure rock and roll.
Andre 3000 doesn't have enough material to be relevant you say?
#%%#!@ from NY determine who is relevant I guess...not the actual quality of the music.....
not.
- 385
- 10
Originally Posted by B Smooth 202
says who?
when it comes to overall artistry we know guys like 3k and Ye are on another level than these rap #%!%!#...
no rapper could ever make a CD close to The Love Below...that %!+% is pure rock and roll.
Andre 3000 doesn't have enough material to be relevant you say?#+!* outta here
#%%#!@ from NY determine who is relevant I guess...not the actual quality of the music.....
not.
I don't buy this "overally artistry" thing you guys try to sell me. I'm judging rappers. I don't listen to this "overall artistry" pop +%+@.
Agreed. Dudes last verse was the Deuces rmx tho.
b smooth 202
Banned
- 10,295
- 106
ok so we're all not supposed to have taste like you?
The Love Below>>>> most rap cds...and thats a fact...this is music bruh...BLACK MUSIC is bigger than RAP MUSIC....
while you poppin bottles cause J Cole sold 200k Outkast is chillin with a diamond plaque
quality>quantity
- 17,867
- 8,142
LOL.
- 14,666
- 2,207
- 60,034
- 50,948
He's rated so high because he's from the south, if he was from NY he wouldn't be rated as high
- 4,053
- 643
Miss with this bs a solo album doesn't mean nothing when dude is primarily a group rapper and his best verse were on his groups albums. Ny dudes come up with the dumbest criteria sometimes seriously .Y'all just mad out of group of seven people with a bunch of affiliates only 4 are actually good when the others are trash . You can't place the wu tang clan judging style on groups with only two members that's completely dumb.when you can hear and judge his best verses on tracks where he only raps with another person not 6.
- 19,198
- 21,020
Not enough out?
- 8,044
- 5,894
cole world 22 is like your friends worrisome little brother that his moms forced to tag along when you was younger..
your boy keeps warning you not to get him started or he wont quit..jus sitting there hanging the bait waiting for somone to bite then boom, instant trolling for hours...
if we all click ignore at once then he wont exist.. hell just dissapear like kevin bacon..
3k is that dude tho to be on topic...i wish he dropped msterial 24/7 like wayne or ross..instead we get a few verses a year...appreciated tho..
your boy keeps warning you not to get him started or he wont quit..jus sitting there hanging the bait waiting for somone to bite then boom, instant trolling for hours...
if we all click ignore at once then he wont exist.. hell just dissapear like kevin bacon..
3k is that dude tho to be on topic...i wish he dropped msterial 24/7 like wayne or ross..instead we get a few verses a year...appreciated tho..
- 823
- 15
Cole World 22- Starlito> Cole
- 254
- 35
This was spot on.
- 385
- 10
Why y'all get so butthert with my tweets?
I answered the the question.
Andre 3k is probably top 20.
If he was from NY, he'd get more credit (FROM OTHERS, NOT ME) from the people (tasteless robots) who judge rappers by their origin, gimmick, etc.
It's like the dudes from NY who don't watch baseball but will rep the Yankees just because they wanna be a a part of a group.
That's what would happen if Andre 3k was from NY.
And yes, I think J. Cole is top 5. Number 4 to be exact.
And that's based off me listening to the music. Not based off what city a rapper is from, what his gimmick is, what his opinion on college is, NONE OF THAT.
My opinion is based STRICTLY on the artist's ability to make RAP music.
I answered the the question.
Andre 3k is probably top 20.
If he was from NY, he'd get more credit (FROM OTHERS, NOT ME) from the people (tasteless robots) who judge rappers by their origin, gimmick, etc.
It's like the dudes from NY who don't watch baseball but will rep the Yankees just because they wanna be a a part of a group.
That's what would happen if Andre 3k was from NY.
And yes, I think J. Cole is top 5. Number 4 to be exact.
And that's based off me listening to the music. Not based off what city a rapper is from, what his gimmick is, what his opinion on college is, NONE OF THAT.
My opinion is based STRICTLY on the artist's ability to make RAP music.
- 37,516
- 13,015
It doesn't matter
1. It is difficult for a person who has strictly been in a group to be the GOAT because for them to be good they have to play off their group member, so part of the reason he is considered so good is how well he and Big Boi mesh.
2. He has very little solo material. And his solo material is much more broad than hip hop
3. He is country.. That's one of the things we like about him.
4. He's top 20 easily (don't give me %%*$ I haven't made the list yet, I just threw out and arbitrary number)... But he honestly is not close to the upper pantheon of hip hop (BIG, Jay-Z, Pac, Nas)
But if it is any solace Outkast is always top of GOAT group lists...
At dude saying J.Cole is number 4 of ALL TIME..... ALL TIME??? You didn't even let that man's debut get at least 2 weeks old before you state stupid @#! opinions
1. It is difficult for a person who has strictly been in a group to be the GOAT because for them to be good they have to play off their group member, so part of the reason he is considered so good is how well he and Big Boi mesh.
2. He has very little solo material. And his solo material is much more broad than hip hop
3. He is country.. That's one of the things we like about him.
4. He's top 20 easily (don't give me %%*$ I haven't made the list yet, I just threw out and arbitrary number)... But he honestly is not close to the upper pantheon of hip hop (BIG, Jay-Z, Pac, Nas)
But if it is any solace Outkast is always top of GOAT group lists...
- 13,432
- 224
Not sure if serious.
- 3,677
- 21
double. #nt is on point
- 3,677
- 21
been saying for a while that cee-lo is the greatest artist of our generation. collectively, outkast is just amazing, however EVERYTHING cee-lo touches turns to gold IMO.
- 3,595
- 12
Lulz at me agreeing with dipsetgeneral. Your absolutely right though
