Our starter home journey. We purchased a 2 bedroom home in Montclair NJ last year for 385k. My Gf was living in Harlem paying $1700 for a studio and I was in Hackensack paying $1450 for a 1 bedroom. The mortgage all in is $2800.
Taxes are low because it's a 2 bedroom (9k vs $16k for 3 bedroom. And the backyard is big enough for an annex of we stay longer than 5 years, although we would never sell the home.
Our dream is to eventually own a condo in Manhattan, we quickly found currently they're outside of our budget at $600k+ and very low inventory.
A few buying factors
1. Direct train to NYC within walking distance - since my girlfriend works in Manhattan. The home is a 2 blocks away and in 40 mins we arrive to Penn Station. Also as similar young couples outgrow their NYC homes, we see Montclair being a spot for values to increase since the town has 4 NJ Tranit train stations, the most of any town.
2. Diversity - Being Latinos we wanted a town that had people of color that represented us. We initially looked at Newark and the homes needed a lot of work and were a car drive to a train station. Surprisingly very low inventory as well.
3. Downtown - a vibrant downtown with byob restaurants, an indie movie theater (only theater in NJ showing Parasite), a performing center (seen Ghostface Killah and Snoop Dogg shows for $15 and walked home afterwards).
Non-negotiables
1. 1/2 bathroom on first floor for guests
2. Good size Yard
3. Driveway wide enough for 2 cars so to avoid backing up for a 2nd car
Photos below. Since we've moved in 15 months ago, there's been 12 renovations within a 3 blocks radius. Everyone is starting to realize that location is amazing with a 5 min walk to the NYC train and downtown. There some downsides with noise and more cars but that's the price for accessibility.
Photos
Basement before and after. Added a full shower, kitchenette, carpet to tile flooring and removed expensive baseboard heating for a ductless unit. We wanted it to be a studio apartment for potential Airbnb income when we retire.