MLB Heads: Choose 1 Player to Clone and Bat 1-9 in Your Lineup, Play Every Position

[wearinthefourfive]

You have a whole pitching staff, but you need someone to play the other 8 positions and DH.

My choice:

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler [+]

Spoiler

Gimme a pocket full of Posey's

 

[el producto79]

Give me 9 Matt Kemps.

 

[bratz dos]

9 Justin Uptons

 

[adobecs4]

Originally Posted by BRaTZ DoS

9 Justin Uptons

 

[kevin cleveland]

Probably Ben Zobrist.

Even if I were to make a more outside the box choice, it would never be someone who is strictly an outfielder.

 

[finallyfamous]

9 Bryce Harpers 

 

[paul is on tilt]

9 Michael Cuddyers.

 

[bostonthreeparty]

Adrian Gonzalez or Ellsbury.

 

[the wizard]

Jose Bautista

 

[jpzx]

Originally Posted by Paul Is On Tilt

9 Michael Cuddyers.

This guy knows.

Only positions he hasn't played this season are catcher and shortstop (meaning he did pitch, and it was a scoreless inning).

 

[proshares]

Originally Posted by Kevin Cleveland

Probably Ben Zobrist.

Even if I were to make a more outside the box choice, it would never be someone who is strictly an outfielder.

+1 or Cuddyer, that's a good one too.

 

[kevin cleveland]

Playing all those positions holds less weight when you're not good at most of them.

 

[wearinthefourfive]

Originally Posted by BostonThreeParty

Adrian Gonzalez or Ellsbury.

Really, 3 adrians patrolling the outfield? Adrian taking shots in the 6 hole?

 

[tim lincecum]

Michael Cuddyer.

 

[pig love]

Adrian played outfield in some interleague games this year when Ortiz played first, he wasn't bad

Gonzo all day 

 

[Retroballer]

9 Lance Berkmans

 

[venom lyrix]

honestly right now...Mike Stanton or Ryan Braun

 

[samb]

Troy Tulowizki for me

 

[proshares]

Braun can barely play the OF

I'd hate to see him in the IF.

 

[bean pie slanga]

Buster Posey ain't playing no damn SS or CF.

 

[kevin cleveland]

They have to play the field, too; he didn't say batting practice.

And if you pick someone that isn't a switch-hitter, you automatically lose.

 

[bb4 86]

i'd take a healthy Joe Mauer

 

[wearinthefourfive]

Originally Posted by Bean Pie Slanga


Buster Posey ain't playing no damn SS or CF.

Gerald played all 9 positions in college

And if you pick someone that isn't a switch-hitter, you automatically lose.
Gerald batted .309 last year vs Lefties, and .304 vs Righties.

 

[dland24]

Originally Posted by bb4 86

i'd take a healthy Joe Mauer

Have a team with 9 homeruns on the season.

I'll take Tulowitzki.

  

 

[john sterling]

1 Derek Jeter









j/k
I guess BJ or Justin Upton