Beans
formerly beans718
- 10,683
- 10,181
Ok you convinced me. They all deserved it ..
What about Clemens? Or arod?
What about Clemens? Or arod?
New York Yankees Official Thread - RIP Former Manager Petey Rose
- Thread in 'Sports & Training' Thread starter Started by アミーゴ,
- Start date
- 29,272
- 11,421
Cmon bro, they ain't going to the HOF why would the Yanks retire 2 rented players numbers.
Paul O'Neil's another one. Heart of those early teams that won. Dude gave everything. Another person who made huge plays and hits when we needed em. Clutch ...
Paul O'Neil's another one. Heart of those early teams that won. Dude gave everything. Another person who made huge plays and hits when we needed em. Clutch ...
- 37,469
- 12,927
Out of all the retired numbers, here is who it is unquestionable:
Martin, Jeter, Ruth, Gehrig, DiMaggio, Torre, Mantle, Berra/Dickey, Rizzuto (for broadcast time), Munson (would have been if he didn’t die), Ford, Mattingly, Howard, Stengel, Rivera, Pettitte
Borderline: Posada, O’Neill, Guidry (fine with all of them not, but also fine if they are)
Who shouldn’t be: Maris, Jackson
Maris got it for 1 crazy year. And Jackson got it for being a personality and 1 huge World Series Game.
Just because it randomly popped in my head, Jackson’s 5 years in NY was comparable to Giambi’s first 5 years like within 10% of each other.
Martin, Jeter, Ruth, Gehrig, DiMaggio, Torre, Mantle, Berra/Dickey, Rizzuto (for broadcast time), Munson (would have been if he didn’t die), Ford, Mattingly, Howard, Stengel, Rivera, Pettitte
Borderline: Posada, O’Neill, Guidry (fine with all of them not, but also fine if they are)
Who shouldn’t be: Maris, Jackson
Maris got it for 1 crazy year. And Jackson got it for being a personality and 1 huge World Series Game.
Just because it randomly popped in my head, Jackson’s 5 years in NY was comparable to Giambi’s first 5 years like within 10% of each other.
Beans
formerly beans718
- 10,683
- 10,181
I mean pettite and mattingly not getting into the HOF either. I’m not for either btw. Just asking the question. Clemens might have more of a claim then you are letting on though.
- 29,272
- 11,421
I agree with Maris and Jackson. Maris broke the record that no one thought would be broken. Reggie had that 3 hr game in the WS . Thats about it as far as i can remember. I actually remember when my uncles and dad went nuts during those times with Reggie doing that. The son of sam days. But i would be weird watchin someone rock 44 again. I think half the time thats what it is. Fans connect guys with the #. Seeing another guys in these #'s would be a downer ...
And chill son , Mattingly is my alltime favorite Yankee..
And chill son , Mattingly is my alltime favorite Yankee..
Beans
formerly beans718
- 10,683
- 10,181
I’m just using your logic papa.. I love mattingly..
- 5,222
- 6,561
I always meant to ask you, what was it like to watch Babe Ruth play?
- 37,469
- 12,927
I’d say time + homegrown are huge factors for why Pettitte is and Clemens isn’t.
But Judge is the only guy who currently doesn’t have a retired number that will.
Cano and ARod should but steroids. Then a lot of needed more time (Clemens, CC, Mussina, Hideki)
dblplay1212
Supporter
- 20,126
- 39,834
Yea but that's more bc he was always on good teams that was always in the playoffs, not bc he was whirling shutouts. He has 276 IP. Next highest is 212 IP lol. He has 35% more IP than nay other pitcher in history.
- 22,584
- 29,207
He showed up in big games when needed. There’s no downplaying his importance to the team during that time.
dblplay1212
Supporter
- 20,126
- 39,834
It's all subjective, but for me, it really falls down to the player needing to be the guy for a long stretch. Guys like Bernie and Posada were good players but Jeter and Mo were always the lead untouchable guys. Mattingly before that. Don't care he never won a chip, he was the guy in NY for 15 years. I'm not mad about the other guys getting their numbers retired, I just wouldn't have voted to do it.
dblplay1212
Supporter
- 20,126
- 39,834
Pettitte? He was good. I'm not arguing he wasn't. He wasn't an elite pitcher thought. Numbers don't lie. I think "He was important to the team!" is a low bar for a retired jersey imo.
- 22,584
- 29,207
Sure you can have this one.
- 29,272
- 11,421
I actually still have the newspaper's of Munson dying and Reggie's 3 HR game. They were my dad's but he left with the shirt on his back so i kept em. As far as Mattingly you youngsters wouldn't understand what he meant here. Yanks were the joke of baseball in the 80's. He was all we had. His grand slams, gold gloves and even being considered the best player in baseball was everything we had to cheer for. Gave us a reason to go to the stadium back then, if not for him that place would've been a graveyard.
This still give me chills and tears
that fan reaction says it all. picture someone else wearing 23 , if u grew up then u couldn't.
dblplay1212
Supporter
- 20,126
- 39,834
I actually still have the newspaper's of Munson dying and Reggie's 3 HR game. They were my dad's but he left with the shirt on his back so i kept em. As far as Mattingly you youngsters wouldn't understand what he meant here. Yanks were the joke of baseball in the 80's. He was all we had. His grand slams, gold gloves and even being considered the best player in baseball was everything we had to cheer for. Gave us a reason to go to the stadium back then, if not for him that place would've been a graveyard.
This still give me chills and tears
that fan reaction says it all. picture someone else wearing 23 , if u grew up then u couldn't.
Yep, will forever and always be my favorite sports moment. It can't get better. He was my childhood. It's different as an old guy rooting for guys half your age lol.
- 37,469
- 12,927
Carpenter to the Padres for $12mil
It’s 2yrs $21mil with options and incentives
It’s 2yrs $21mil with options and incentives
- 28,935
- 17,602
Overpay can’t see him staying healthy
- 29,272
- 11,421
dblplay1212
Supporter
- 20,126
- 39,834
Yikes
- 10,246
- 8,501
You think Giants are having buyers remorse and looking for a reason to lower or cut the contract?
- 28,935
- 17,602
essential1
you also collecting Yankees cards?I’ve got like 15-20 Judge PSA 10 rookies - starting the collection back up for my someday little guy to take over. He’s getting 12 Mantle autos already
dblplay1212
Supporter
- 20,126
- 39,834
Na MLBPA would sue them to oblivion if they try to back out and it's not legit.
dblplay1212
Supporter
- 20,126
- 39,834
- 37,469
- 12,927
I’ve got like 15-20 Judge PSA 10 rookies - starting the collection back up for my someday little guy to take over. He’s getting 12 Mantle autos already
Yes and no.
I’m all over the place with collecting.
- 28,935
- 17,602
Same - starting to hop back in so little man has the best collection of all time.
Flying the seats from the old stadium up now for my basement
