- 3,709
- 622
- Joined
- Jul 18, 2012
Performances are more what hooks me. The grit and exuberance of Brett Favre, the precision of Peyton, Brady's killer instinct, McNair's fortitude. Witnessing one or two of those type games from any of them helped me differentiate between levels of individual greatness. Usually, most these guys have that one thing that no one else can match. Some won Super Bowls, others didnt, but it's those respective qualities along with steady success is why I don't really care to list a top 5. Some days teams need a Brett Favre, others they need a Marino to whip it around all over. This thread picked apart a lot of greats, which furthers my view...Not one of them is perfect and in all likelihood, not all are interchangeable. It's those individual qualities that make them standout for me.
Last edited: