- 5,667
- 6,627
RJ is the one going in any of these trades. That's clearly the spot that they're trying to upgrade
Official '24-'25 knicks season thread, KAT
- Thread in 'Sports & Training' Thread starter Started by pr0phecy718,
- Start date
- 73,551
- 100,526
I could be pretty easily sold on a straight Barrett for OG swap but I'm not a fan of giving RJ+ for him.
- 10,246
- 8,501
I’d figure they’d want a lineup of Brunson, RJ, OG, Julius and Mitch. With the bench 2 Harts, Donte and whoever else.
- 10,246
- 8,501
If RJ is traded straight up for OG that means we gotta sign IQ to an extension
- 35,383
- 27,007
Turned a bit cold on OG. Feel like he's a player who would struggle offensively in a playoff setting.
- 73,551
- 100,526
oh no we have to extend the 24 year old who was the best defender on the team & sixth man of the year runner up
- 12,393
- 7,890
is IQ gonna start? you're cool with giving a backup 25mil per?
for a team that struggled offensively in the playoffs, you're going to trade your 2nd best player for an older player that can't score on his own.
ok.
if RJ didnt step up in the playoffs and Randle played well, then trading for OG makes sense. idc what guys do in the regular season if they cant do anything when it matters. as much as some of you dont like RJ, he stepped up when our all-nba and sixth man runner up did not.
for a team that struggled offensively in the playoffs, you're going to trade your 2nd best player for an older player that can't score on his own.
ok.
if RJ didnt step up in the playoffs and Randle played well, then trading for OG makes sense. idc what guys do in the regular season if they cant do anything when it matters. as much as some of you dont like RJ, he stepped up when our all-nba and sixth man runner up did not.
- 10,246
- 8,501
I would’nt be mad if we signed him to an extension I was just saying we couldn’t trade RJ and IQ.
- 74,930
- 24,346
Let’s trade RJ for someone who can’t score. Good move.
- 10,246
- 8,501
- 74,930
- 24,346
RJ scored more than 20 6/10 games in the playoffs this year and was our second most consistent player. But sure. He’s marginally better.
- 10,246
- 8,501
RJ averaged 19 shooting 43 in the playoffs and the last playoffs OG was in he averaged 17 on 47. But sure RJ is a scorer and OG isn’t based of 2ppg.
- 35,383
- 27,007
Its more so that if the motive is to eventually trade RJ, I rather him be involved in a package for an actual all-star caliber player.
- 10,509
- 8,972
Agreed. If it's not for an all star player then what's the point. Might as well continue to develop him. 19-20ppg behind two other ball dominant players is pretty decent. I wish Thibs would run more plays for RJ than just trying to let him cook via ISO. Also wish he would return to shooting well from the 3.
- 5,667
- 6,627
^ this or an all defensive team player that shoots 39% from 3?
- 35,383
- 27,007
OG is 26 years old and has been the same player for the last 3 seasons.
Also, is defense really our main issue?
Also, is defense really our main issue?
- 35,383
- 27,007
Fun fact: Quentin Grimes hit more 3pters this season than OG Anunoby and at the same %
Where was this in the playoffs? Thats my main fear with OG, I dont think he's that guy.
Where was this in the playoffs? Thats my main fear with OG, I dont think he's that guy.
- 10,246
- 8,501
Don’t do this B, You were talking playoff performance earlier and Grimes was arguably our worst playoff performer. Shot 30/24
- 10,246
- 8,501
If we keeping it real, Based off of solely stats, OG is not that far of a drop off on offense from RJ. Everyone complained about RJs defense and getting tunnel vision on his Drives or fast breaks but would’nt take an all NBA defensive player who shoots better from 3 and overall and only averages 3 less points a game and more than makes up for those 3 points on the defensive end and offensive efficiency for RJ?
- 10,246
- 8,501
Again not saying I’d want an RJ for OG swap but now OG is now old and a far inferior player to RJ?!?
- 12,393
- 7,890
They’re not far off, but it would be a lateral move which is a waste of a move just to make one. Why break up chemistry we already have, if it’s not for a significant upgrade. OG doesn’t move the needle or get us passed Miami.
- 10,246
- 8,501
if Grimes and IQ played even remotely like NBA players we would’ve been in the finals.
- 12,393
- 7,890
agreed. Randle had a all nba season right before the extension and hasn’t performed in the playoffs. IQ was the sixth man runner up and didn’t perform in the playoffs. If we extend him at 100mil and he again disappears in the playoffs, I’m gonna be sick. At this stage, I’d rather have a proven vet that can make shots and the right play when it matters.
- 10,246
- 8,501
We pretty much knew Randle was going to struggle, but to have 2 players play worse than Randle that were big parts of our regular season and still had a chance to beat Miami says a lot.
- 35,383
- 27,007
Looking at Randles playoff stats this year. Wow didn’t think they were THAT bad.
