Official Linguistics Thread

Joined
Jun 28, 2004
Messages
8,369
Reaction score
20,985
Once again, another spillover and compliment to the Politics Thread

Linguistics and History and politics are closely link. For example, English lacks a distinction an inclusive and exclusive "we." Perhaps if we had a definitely inclusive "we," the liberal refrain of "we are stronger together," might have been interpreted by swing voters who felt left out from the economic prosperity of major cities. Maybe Hillary wins in 2016 if we had an inclusive "we" rather than our ambiguous "we."


We might as well start with the language of this board, English and it's past and relationship to places as diverse as Iceland and Bengal.

Here's the whole video, from the start.




Here's where he gets to the meat of it by comparing numbers from England, Italy, and South Asia.




Pancha is probably why we have the word "punch" since it was made of five things: hard liquor, sugar, citrus, water/tea, and nutmeg.


So this is just the first post.

We have an extremely diverse community here and if any one knows any idioms, common sayings, from a language that they know, other than English, please drop them in here with a literal translation into English of said idiom.


Edit: languages are always in flux so it can be hard to find these similarities. One of my favorite examples is that the German word for any animal is "Tier" but the English world is animal, an obviously Latinate word. However, deer sounds a lot like Tier and wouldn't you know it, the ancient Anglo-Saxons called all animals deer.

English is a faster moving and highly dynamic language whereas German is more static and conservative.

German is full of words which are obviously cognates with the King James Bible Germans call pigs Schwein which sounds a lot like Swine. Same for the sky, Germans say Himmel and in older versions of English we called the sky "the Heavens." German is basically like 17th century English in many ways. The examples go on and on.


But yeah, solving these puzzles is even more fun to me than Economics, TBH.
 
Last edited:
Interested, will try to support with some sayings in Haitian Creole when I get the chance

I'm not conversant in Haitian Creole butI do respect that they figured out that, wait, you actually just spell French and French derived and Afro-French words, phonetically.




I'm not an expert in this field but I can tell if someone was part of that Second Great Migration, from the South to the West Coast.

AAVE is interesting because segregation created a distinct dialect of American English, but because the US is so large, there's then dialects within a dialect.
 
The evolution of language is interesting. I follow this guy on TikTok

 


fantastic video, IMO.

I love linguistics for the same reason I lobe History. I like visting other people's headspaces.

AS always I'd love for people to comment and, more importantly, contribute a non-engliash feature in your own language.
 
Interesting idea for a thread. I'm for it. Checking out the videos you've suggested and putting them in my Watch Laters. Appreciate it.
 


fantastic video, IMO.

I love linguistics for the same reason I lobe History. I like visting other people's headspaces.

AS always I'd love for people to comment and, more importantly, contribute a non-engliash feature in your own language.

Good video. I'm sure there are tons more features.

Funny part is, we could add some of these features to English if we like them. Just start using them. Humans made up English. We can start changing whatever we want and in a few decades it might make it in.
 
People also have to stop getting dialect/lingo confused with an accent.

Floridians don’t have an accent. We have different lingos. Cats from Baltimore and New Orleans have an accent
 
I am no way a linguistic person. However, having studied German, I find the connection fascinating. The connection stems from England being a colony of Denmark then being conquered by Normans. This way there is also a heavy French influence as well within English.

I will respond more in depth later but yes, German is a bit like a Frankstein language. There are still many Germanic words in English such Haus, Glas, Mein, Kann, Kannt, Bier, Hund and Fleisch. Also many letters switch from V to F and also Z to C.

For example, in German it is Volks but in English it is Folks. And it's pretty much pronounced the same way. And the example that I can think of at the moment about Z to C is in the name of Franziska, which is Francesca in English. In addition, a K will turn into C as well when translation is applied.

Great topic, my the way 👍
 
Back
Top Bottom