Originally Posted by
shogun
Originally Posted by
Mojodmonky1
Originally Posted by shogun
^
I won't disagree with that one but a few of the contenders would give him problems. Styles are very important.
If he was given a title shot right away then he'd have a good chance against Frankie or Gray. He might have a tougher time against guys like Jim Miller, Henderson, Melvin and maybe even Pettis.
not sure i agree with the "eat him alive" prediction.
I dont think Edgar gets enough credit. While he may not be the biggest 155er, its not like he was overpowered by some bigger and/or stronger 155ers like Maynard or BJ. While Aldo is lightning quick, Edgar is no slouch when it comes to the speed dept.
I just dont know what Bendo or Pettis could bring against Aldo that would make them any more successful than Edgar would be.
Frankie is my favorite lightweight and seeing him almost get knocked out by Gray was a big surprise for me. If Aldo connects then he'd be in big trouble. I'm one of the only ones who have defended Frankie and talked about how he's gotten stronger. He's showed it in his fights with Sherk, BJ and Maynard. His boxing is great but he lacks power. His wrestling is top 2 in the division so I don't doubt he can get takedowns and win the fight there.
Bendo's standup is pretty bad so he'll go for takedowns the whole time. Aldo's a big FW, but we have to see how he matches up strength wise with the huge LW's. If he gets taken down, can he get back up? Can he sub off his back against guys with smothering top control?