Here's what I saw in 2012..
The Devil Inside (January 6th)
Chronicle (February 3rd)
The Hunger Games (March 23rd)
The Raid: Redemption (March 23rd)
American Reunion (April 6th)
The Cabin in the Woods (April 13th)
The Avengers (May 4th)
Men In Black 3 (May 25th)
Prometheus (June 8th)
Ted (June 29th)
The Amazing Spider-Man (July 3rd)
The Dark Knight Rises (July 20th)
Hope Springs (August 8th)
The Campaign (August 10th)
The Expendables 2 (August 17th)
The Possession (August 31st)
Looper (September 28th)
Argo (Ocotber 12th)
Sinister (October 12th)
Skyfall (October 26th)
Wreck-It Ralph (November 2nd)
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (December 14th)
This is 40 (December 21st)
Django Unchained (December 25th)
If I had to make a Top-10...
The Raid: Redemption
Wreck-It Ralph
The Avengers
Prometheus
Looper
Django Unchained
The Dark Knight Rises
Skyfall
The Cabin in the Woods
Argo
And commenting on the top 5.
Django was excellent, and everything I wanted from it, but there wasn't anything there put it over the top and made it better than what I expected. I had the same expectations going into Iglourious Basterds, but I felt like it was better than I was hoping for. I loved Django, and other than Cabin/Avengers it might've been my favorite theatrical experience of the year, but it didn't go above and beyond to make it my favorite of the year. The pacing was great though, one of the weakpoints I thought of IB.
The Dark Knight Rises moved me to tears, and I actually liked Bane as much as The Joker (one of the few who thought so). This might've been ranked higher if the other films didn't blow me away as much as they did. TDKR isn't higher because I knew it was going to be great, and I loved what they did with it, and may enjoy it more than TDK. Bale, Caine, Hardy, Hathaway all left me with my jaw on the floor, and the ending was a perfect way to end it IMO. It was the film that I was the most emotionally invested in, and the payoff at the end was excellent.
Skyfall is ranked so high for me because I had little-to-no expectations going into Skyfall, but after seeing it I was enthralled with the lore of James Bond. Javier was such an excellent villain and there were some true moments of tension that I hadn't felt in a Bond film before. If Bond films continue to go on like this, I'll be very happy. It was a great entry to a slacking series of films.
The Cabin in the Woods was such a refreshing and revitalizing shock to the horror genre that it goes this high for me. I know no one else will call Cabin their second favorite film of the year, but for me, it was that good. I went in not knowing anything of the film, and ended scratching my head not realizing how awesome this was going to be. It was humorous, it was smart, and it was innovative. The tone sold the film for me, and I just hope that The Evil Dead remake next year is half as good as this was.
Argo takes the cake for me. I'm a sucker for period pieces, and Affleck has done it again. The Town was great, Argo was amazing. I felt like not only I was watching a 70s film, I felt like I was in the 70s. Not to mention being the most tense film of the entire year, it was just excellently paced, and it's even better when you didn't know about the incident and it hits you over the head with non-stop apprehension. I'm not sure if many other feels this way, but Argo just took me to a place where I want to be in films, like I'm right in the middle of it.