If you go to St. Johns you're either:
A) missing out on a real college experience (college town, grass quads, a real greek life, townies supporting anything related to the school, etc)
B) missing out on a true NYC living. Ya, you can take the train in from Queens but it's nothing like going to NYU or Hunter, or even Columbia even tho it's in the North Pole. At the end of the day, young people, 18 - 23 move to NYC to be right in the thick of it all, not in the outskirts of Queens. This ain't Coming to America.
I just can't see 4 and 5 star recruits outside of NYC being enticed by Jamaica Queens and the environment there.