- 5,839
- 5,415
on now
Last edited:
The Official PlayStation Thread Vol. 5 | SOP Today 3PM PST / NEW Firmware Update is LIVE / PS5 Pro launches 11/7 for $699
- Thread in 'General' Thread starter Started by iheartboost,
- Start date
- 9,926
- 4,103
Why is Alan Wake in the running for GOTY? I know its a great game, But I thought that there was supposed to be a limit on how recent a game can be before it can be nominated. Same goes for RE4make IMO. Why have a remake in the running in a year full of stellar releases?
- 17,511
- 8,571
How did Diablo 4 not make it? 
Strange list, but its a 3-4 horse race regardless.
Strange list, but its a 3-4 horse race regardless.
- 10,843
- 16,019
Ya that's a weak list!
- 9,926
- 4,103
- 13,818
- 13,118
How did Diablo 4 not make it?
Diablo 4 has poor replay value. It’s been pretty underwhelming tbh.
- 25,086
- 12,562
Those psn game deals don’t even hit like before.
- 9,926
- 4,103
Baldur's Gate 3 definitely has GOTY locked in. Its been a long time since Ive played a game with that amount of content and replay-ability. I'm literally already planning my 3rd playthrough, which I'm going to go into right after I finish my current run.How did Diablo 4 not make it?
Ricky D
formerly centex hogg
- 19,422
- 14,192
I think the cutoff for GotY is sometime in late November. Ragnarok was nominated last year and released on 11/9. Not sure what yall were expecting
The only games I could see possibly overtaking RE4 is maybe Diablo IV (people were upset with the post game content), FF XVI (people claimed it wasn’t a FF game) or Starfield (not really sure, media claimed there were all sorts of bugs etc. but didn’t seem to have any issue nominating Spider-Man 2 despite the progression breaking bugs)
Oh and if we’re going to question RE4, I’d do the same for BG3. The game was purchasable and being played for the last 3 years
The only games I could see possibly overtaking RE4 is maybe Diablo IV (people were upset with the post game content), FF XVI (people claimed it wasn’t a FF game) or Starfield (not really sure, media claimed there were all sorts of bugs etc. but didn’t seem to have any issue nominating Spider-Man 2 despite the progression breaking bugs)
Oh and if we’re going to question RE4, I’d do the same for BG3. The game was purchasable and being played for the last 3 years
- 17,511
- 8,571
I think you underestimate how many people love Zelda. I'd be surprised if it doesnt win.
I'd be surprised if it doesnt win.
- 25,086
- 12,562
Zelda running away with most goty awards.
- 42,322
- 44,204
Spider-Man believes otherwise. Lol its literally Nintendo vs Sony. This match up has been brewing for decades.
Ricky D
formerly centex hogg
- 19,422
- 14,192
Spider-Man 2 has 0% chance of winning GotY. This is a 2 way race between BG3 and Zelda.
BG3 is going to win.
BG3 is going to win.
- 3,557
- 3,963
Idk why ppl act like awards shows mean anything. Most people paying for that position on award list
swendro
formerly swendro88
- 12,994
- 9,364
Maybe I’m biased because I think TotK is a 7, but my money is on BG 3 to win goty.
- 17,511
- 8,571
I dont think any of us in here really think award shows mean anything. Its just a fun discussion topic. Personally, my top 5 from 2023 arent anywhere to be seen.
Awards DO mean something to devs though. Some have bonuses tied to review scores and awards if I remember correctly.
Its just a fun discussion topic. Personally, my top 5 from 2023 arent anywhere to be seen.Awards DO mean something to devs though. Some have bonuses tied to review scores and awards if I remember correctly.
- 18,766
- 10,165
- 8,007
- 5,142
Guess I gotta get BG3 now
- 5,839
- 5,415
BG3 is my GOTY
One of those games that tires me out when I'm playing.
When I'm not playing, all I'm doing is planning my next sessions.
The amount of influence and different scenarios YOU create is insane
Score is epic, acting on point, combat took some time to nail, but i get it now.
Wouldn't have picked that particular actor for his performance
but that's because he got dropped out of my party for some stuff I couldn't stand.
Looks like I'll ride him out for my 3rd run.
One of those games that tires me out when I'm playing.
When I'm not playing, all I'm doing is planning my next sessions.
The amount of influence and different scenarios YOU create is insane
Score is epic, acting on point, combat took some time to nail, but i get it now.
Wouldn't have picked that particular actor for his performance
but that's because he got dropped out of my party for some stuff I couldn't stand.
Looks like I'll ride him out for my 3rd run.
- 16,943
- 46,935
Ill probably end up copping the PC version when it goes on sale or something. I have tge old games but never could get into the old sprite based WRPGs.
Ricky D
formerly centex hogg
- 19,422
- 14,192
BG3 was on my wishlist until I realized it was point and click.
- 9,277
- 23,698
Probably the GOAT Fantasy WRPG in my eyes overtaking the likes of Dragon's Age. The amount of freedom and options is legit insane.
T0INE
formerly toine2983
- 67,219
- 73,650
- 18,766
- 10,165
John Wick
formerly jayzonmytoes
- 7,257
- 3,028
Im about to start my first playthrou on bg3 over lol
But finally put an end to SP2 great game this is what a full priced single player game experience should be nice and smooth playthrough on the hardest difficulty
But finally put an end to SP2 great game this is what a full priced single player game experience should be nice and smooth playthrough on the hardest difficulty
