Which MLB team has the sickest lineup to date?

[sonickicks]

1. Detroit Tigers
Current batting order: (1) Curtis Granderson, CF; (2) Placido Polanco, 2B; (3) Miguel Cabrera, 3B; (4) Gary Sheffield, DH; (5) Magglio Ordonez, RF; (6) Carlos Guillen, 1B; (7) Edgar Renteria, SS; (

Pudge Rodriguez, C; (9) Jacque Jones,

 

[ironmanfitness]

^ you dont know about sheffield health, edgar rentaria is unproven in american league

yanks

damon- played amazing at the end bc was in shape
jeter
abreu- playing in a contract year stats should stay the same or go up
arod- is god
posada- potential decline
matsui
cano- things looking up
melky
giambi

overall yanks are better and have proven it in the stat category

angels havnt dont jack this offseason and their offense will decline quick

 

[27th4thehood]

Originally Posted by IronmanFitness

^ you dont know about sheffield health, edgar rentaria is unproven in american league

yanks

damon- played amazing at the end bc was in shape
jeter
abreu- playing in a contract year stats should stay the same or go up
arod- is god
posada- potential decline
matsui
cano- things looking up
melky
giambi

overall yanks are better and have proven it in the stat category

angels havnt dont jack this offseason and their offense will decline quick

u still hating on us?

 

[mez 0ne]

Detroit has a better lineup than the Yankees, sorry.

 

[sonickicks]

LoL 300 Million to buy a God, Why didn't they invest or upgrading in pitching. You can have a God in a team but Pitching still win games. Besides baseballis a team sport. Baseball is not about 1 player.

 

[koolbarbone]

Originally Posted by IronmanFitness

^ you dont know about sheffield health, edgar rentaria is unproven in american league

After one year with the Red Sox he's proven that he sucks in the AL.

 

[ironmanfitness]

^ nah they dont but thanks lo duca.....the bottom of detroits lineup has terrible slugging percentage including sheffield

 

[barondavis5]

Im gonna say the Tigers

 

[sonickicks]

Miguel Cabrera = Baby Rod.

 

[am 1 fiend]

The Red Sox are still#%@%+++*! on your squads.

 

[infyrno23]

the Tiger homie....
is there any question?

 

[tbone95860]

Originally Posted by AM 1 FIEND

The Red Sox are still#%@%+++*! on your squads.

No.......

The Red Sox hitting doesn't touch the Yankees hitting.

The Red Sox just had better pitching last year.

 

[sonickicks]

If Red Sox cop santana it would be another yr for them. I think i would not watch baseball for a yr.

 

[flatbushfiyah23]

I gotta go with the Yankees when healthy over Detroit but its not by much. I think you can really go either way.

 

[dunknforce]

NYY

 

[am 1 fiend]

Originally Posted by TBONE95860

Originally Posted by AM 1 FIEND

The Red Sox are still#%@%+++*! on your squads.

No.......

The Red Sox hitting doesn't touch the Yankees hitting.

The Red Sox just had better pitching last year.

Which is exactly why your squad doesn't win World Series anymore. Pitching is everything and a great line up consist of all-stars and role players, notHome Run derby like some teams (Yanks, Tigers) assemble

 

[tbone95860]

Originally Posted by AM 1 FIEND

Originally Posted by TBONE95860

Originally Posted by AM 1 FIEND

The Red Sox are still#%@%+++*! on your squads.

No.......

The Red Sox hitting doesn't touch the Yankees hitting.

The Red Sox just had better pitching last year.

Which is exactly why your squad doesn't win World Series anymore. Pitching is everything and a great line up consist of all-stars and role players, not Home Run derby like some teams (Yanks, Tigers) assemble

ok the question is who has the best LINE-UP not overall team.......

 

[TheGodFresco]

SF Giants

 

[paul is 0n nt]

Originally Posted by GSDOUBLEU

SF Giants

They make me sick to my stomach.

 

[ady2glude707]

NYY lineup is ishing on everyone else

 

[kiddin like jason]

Overall, the Tigers lineup is tops.

 

[am 1 fiend]

Originally Posted by TBONE95860

Originally Posted by AM 1 FIEND

Originally Posted by TBONE95860

Originally Posted by AM 1 FIEND

The Red Sox are still#%@%+++*! on your squads.

No.......

The Red Sox hitting doesn't touch the Yankees hitting.

The Red Sox just had better pitching last year.

Which is exactly why your squad doesn't win World Series anymore. Pitching is everything and a great line up consist of all-stars and role players, not Home Run derby like some teams (Yanks, Tigers) assemble

ok the question is who has the best LINE-UP not overall team.......

How did that Yankee lineup do for you in the post season?

 

[atljunkie]

Detroit has a better lineup than the Yankees, sorry.


I think the Tigers >> any other team too.

 

[wstcoastgotti]

George Mitchell has a pretty damn good lineup right about now

 

[kaygeedagr8]

THE FLORIDA MARLINS!!! Yep I said it!!!