I think it depends on the kind of black music you're talking about but I feel what you're saying. Any random person can analyze and break down a song like the DS2 intro
But some stuff you need a little more knowledge. A random head off the street ain't bout to successfully analyze a full dead prez album or fully grasp something like TPAB in all its overrated glory.
Like it's been stated it's a cultural thing. There are themes and words and feelings that some people, even some black people, just aren't gonna get. It's like this with other kinds of music too.
And even then it's less "this white dude reviewing our music" and more "these white dudes are deciding what's hot in our culture, along with these other white dudes exploiting it for their own gain". I love that all races of people embrace things that we do. But I hate that what we do is distorted, stolen, and repackaged once the realization hits that it could be exploited. It was like this before hip hop and it will be after.
It sucks because one of the few things we have as our own isn't even in our control now. We aren't even the biggest consumers of our own music here and I think that has a lot to do with it.
I typed too much though I'm done now