- 7,884
- 2,014
This is glorious
2024 MLB Thread; RIP Willie Mays & Pete Rose. Dodgers win #8!
- Thread in 'Sports & Training' Thread starter Started by CP1708,
- Start date
Bend_The_Knee
formerly gotholesinmysocks
- 61,798
- 23,535
Luhnow will get another job in 2021. How he built that roster was impressive.
- 17,811
- 43,325
disgusting...
- 23,359
- 26,359
nah it’ll be awhile imo he gonna have to wait to get that stink off him
T0INE
formerly toine2983
- 67,151
- 73,545
Well damn.
Was not expecting dudes to get fired on their day off.
Was not expecting dudes to get fired on their day off.
- 25,274
- 13,331
I agree - it's as harsh as it realistically could be.
Stripping titles and wins and **** is stupid - glad they didn't go that route, even though... F*** the Astros.
There's not much else the MLB could've done.
This punishment was always gonna be at some level inconsequential.
- 35,431
- 77,927
Pretty much. It's like Paterno, MSU in regards to Larry Nassar, etc. Inaction is action.
- 23,380
- 5,473
Not the one vs Houston. They did get handled vs Boston
Bend_The_Knee
formerly gotholesinmysocks
- 61,798
- 23,535
If they did take the title from them, then you have to investigate every team that has won a world series, no?
Astros and Red Sox are not the only teams who have cheated.
Astros and Red Sox are not the only teams who have cheated.
do work son
Banned
- 17,118
- 5,186
Cant take it away from me.
I believe Dodger fans genuinely expected to have the World Series title given to them, along with Bregman for a Double A relief pitcher and maybe Altuve for a 40 year old catcher or something.
- 11,425
- 18,484
Would’ve loved to see Boston and Houston both be ruled playoff ineligible for a few seasons, the way college teams got the hammer dropped to where they couldn’t play in bowl games.
Give the current players on this teams who weren’t on the roster in 2017-18 an option to opt out of their contract.
Give the current players on this teams who weren’t on the roster in 2017-18 an option to opt out of their contract.
- 12,091
- 13,183
As a Dodger fan I don’t expect the title given to LA, I just don’t want the Astros to be considered champs. I’m petty enough to accept an official asterisk acknowledged by MLB at this point.
A retroactive title wouldn’t undo the things a lot of us experienced during that 7 game series. So many of those games were neck and neck. The 2018 WS I don’t care about, even if there was some cheating, because BoSox were purely better. However, that 2017 stings, especially knowing some Houston fans are smug enough to still feel they deserved that title despite all of this.
A retroactive title wouldn’t undo the things a lot of us experienced during that 7 game series. So many of those games were neck and neck. The 2018 WS I don’t care about, even if there was some cheating, because BoSox were purely better. However, that 2017 stings, especially knowing some Houston fans are smug enough to still feel they deserved that title despite all of this.
- 39,291
- 40,712
manfred gotta look the other way and let Kershaw get on some hgh in for the playoffs like andy petite
- 27,205
- 64,351
Not enough.
- 37,127
- 14,107
Think of being a Houston sports fans the last 24 hours
- 28,097
- 9,221
People who are advocating for the title to be stripped are not advocating that the title is given to LA. Lol
Blows my mind that people think this is a harsh enough penalty. MLB needed a penalty harsh enough to deter teams from doing this in the future. I bet there are maybe 3 teams in all of baseball that wouldnt gladly give up what the Astros did for a World Series.
Title should be stripped. Houston should not be allowed to profit off of said title in any way.
5 mil in fines, losing a couple players and 2 suspensions is deemed harsh. That's laughable IMO.
Blows my mind that people think this is a harsh enough penalty. MLB needed a penalty harsh enough to deter teams from doing this in the future. I bet there are maybe 3 teams in all of baseball that wouldnt gladly give up what the Astros did for a World Series.
Title should be stripped. Houston should not be allowed to profit off of said title in any way.
5 mil in fines, losing a couple players and 2 suspensions is deemed harsh. That's laughable IMO.
Bend_The_Knee
formerly gotholesinmysocks
- 61,798
- 23,535
Think of being a Houston sports fans the last 24 hours
Those 46 people must be going nuts.
- 60,034
- 50,947
Go back and play that 2017 series against the Yankees, old roster or currents roster.
- 11,425
- 18,484
Houston should be ineligible for postseason play for a few years, regardless of what their record is.
- 37,127
- 14,107
Now that's a hammer, but it would be a waste of a season for them to play then.
- 20,501
- 15,096
Manfred's full 9 page statement: https://img.mlbstatic.com/mlb-images/image/upload/mlb/cglrhmlrwwbkacty27l7.pdf
- 11,425
- 18,484
Would set the organization back , attendance would be down. I doubt anyone else would try something similar.
Just to be fair. Give anyone on the current team who wasn’t on the roster in 2017 the option to terminate their contract and become a free agent.
- 12,091
- 13,183
It would be weird to get it now though, so just vacate it like NCAA does. A lot of people can rightfully argue that it could've been the Yanks' title, which I definitely understand.
