So many opinions out here. I last left a comment here around page 25 on the mobile version of NT, read the next few postings and had to post again.
Anyway, this shoe is horrible. It really is. Growing up waiting to see what JB will release the next year, there was always a performance upgrade. So, an argument where OG "sneakerheads" don't like these is pretty much invalid.
Personally, I've liked every shoe that JB has released in their signature Roman numeral series. Even if the original shoe was terrible (XIXs) Jordan brand changed them and I was happy with them (like releasing low tops or the SEs) You can still play basketball with them and they were stylish.
I hope that JB does the same with these. I think they will, too. They may make a model similar to what they did with the XIXs and expose the part of the shoe that is covered.
Ultimately, the phrase we all like to use, "To each their own" will always apply. If you like them, buy them. If you don't like them, don't buy them. Simple.
Side Note: I would never play basketball with low top shoes. The drop in weight and slight increase in mobility is not worth potentially straining your ankles severely. Mid and high tops help prevent those kind of injuries.