Edward Norton in Fight Club or American History X????

[scarface2k1]

thats def a tough call.
his performance is the 25th hour was unreal!

 

[harlemtothebronx]

I think American History X is the better story, so American History X.

 

[jordan23 4xl]

Originally Posted by ILL LEGAL OPERATION

American History X.

 

[dirtylicious]

My personal favourite Norton role is Primal Fear though.
ditto on that

 

[darth dnzy]

--The combination of Norton and Pitt in Fight Club was awesome, making it the better movie (just by a little bit)
--But Norton's overall individual performance in American History X was more powerful than his Jack/Tyler Durden one.

 

[GL Rayner]

American History X

 

[babyfacedassassin31]

Primal fear beats them both.

Hes so believable all the way through u believe he couldnt have hurt a fly he seems so innocent until they make him snap near the end and hes crazy scary.

American History X is one of my all time fav movies dont really care for Fight Club.

Id say hes underrated because he hasnt consistently done good movies since the 90s.

Peace
Scottie

 

[lexflex81]

Originally Posted by Big J 33

Originally Posted by twol8

i never seen the 25th hour... is it one of those must watches?

Not really, but it's still a good movie with a very good performance by Norton.

Best quote of the movie: "Champagne for my real friends, and real pain for my sham friends."

Mr Norton rules!

 

[r31j23]

25th hour.
if i have to choose fight club

 

[kicks4kaskets]

Fight Club

 

[drameezy]

i dont like his acting in flight club,
but it is the better movie...

 

[enlightened thought]

^what he said.

brad pitt owned fight club. ed norton, though, was just something else in American History X.

 

[j4kicks21]

Primal Fear

 

[johnnyredstorm]

Originally Posted by l Silky Johnston l

Fight club is a terrible movie but American History X is a good movie.

Don't ever speak about movies again.

Anyways, his performances in Primal Fear and American History X are the best of his career. Y'all gotta check out The Illusionist. Really awesome moviethat he killed.

 

[richkarlmarx]

Originally Posted by JohnnyRedStorm

Originally Posted by l Silky Johnston l

Fight club is a terrible movie but American History X is a good movie.

Don't ever speak about movies again.

Anyways, his performances in Primal Fear and American History X are the best of his career. Y'all gotta check out The Illusionist. Really awesome movie that he killed.

for real man. you might not think fight club is a perfect movie. but its amazing on so many levels. ill check out primal fear too, never seen it

 

[frankreynolds420]

I've never seen Primal, so I might have to retract my previous statement. But I know 25th hour is terrible, The Illusionist( a poor mans "ThePrestige"), The Hulk, both sucked as well.

 

[robaf1]

American History X, i have both on DVD, I can never finish Fight Club, its slow and not my style. AHX however, hes badasssss

 

[drock2010]

Originally Posted by kash55

Tough call.

Yeah I love both these movies

I give the edge to American History X though

 

[proshares]

AHX.

 

[fanatic15]

Norton is hot. I would choose Fight Club because it's one of my favorite movies of all time but you can't go wrong w/ either. Great Actor.

 

[hiphopjunkie]

He was bad In American History X got all big for the role and played it perfect.. as for flight club can't say only watched a little of it