MLB Heads: Choose 1 Player to Clone and Bat 1-9 in Your Lineup, Play Every Position

[the wizard]

Originally Posted by Kevin Cleveland

They have to play the field, too; he didn't say batting practice.

And if you pick someone that isn't a switch-hitter, you automatically lose.

Not true. I'd take my chances with Bautista who is getting on base with LHP & RHP.

Who is to say that any of these players that have played multiple positions briefly would have the ability to field these positions adequately for 9 innings and 162 games?

I'd take the offense over the defense because defense is players + pitching. You can have the best defensive team, but if your pitcher is serving up gopher balls, there is nothing you can do defensively. You could also have a pitcher that has a high K/rate and doesn't rely on his defense as extensively and be fine. There are alot of variables such as home ballparks & pitching rotations that are unknown, so I would pick the one thing I can control which is the hitting.

 

[fenixconnexion.]

Originally Posted by The Wizard

Jose Bautista

co-sign

joey bats has consistently played 3b and RF this season which means hes a solid infielder and outfielder. not to mention he can hit RHP and LHP well. 

 

[ThaxbyChamblis]

9 thetruth03's

 

[abovelegit1]

Jose Reyes

 

[wildkycat]

 

[statis22]

9 Jacoby Ellsburys. BRINKS!!!

 

[statis22]

Yuku'd

 

[caerus]

Barry Bonds #GAMEOVER 162-0

 

[statis22]

So thorough it posted twice. Or 9 Craig Biggios

 

[blazerfan]

C - Dylan
1B - Dylan
2B - Dylan
3B - Dylan
SS - Dylan
LF - Dylan
CF - Dylan
RF - Dylan


Gimmie 9 Asdrubal's on defense lol.