NFL Quarterbacks Discussion thread: 2013 Edition

[cruzzz]

1. Rodgers

2. Brady

3. P. Manning

4. Brees

5. Big Ben

6. Eli

7.Romo

8.Ryan

9. Flacco

10 RG3/Russell Wilson

 

[hymen man]

Christian Ponder.

 

[651akathepaul]

Christian Ponder.

What about him?

 

[hymen man]

He's da best.

 

[651akathepaul]

 

[cruzzz]

 

[jayfiend]

gimme russ instead of rg3, flip eli and big ben nd i think thats an accurate list...

What makes Wilson better than RG3?

 

[theswagofsweetjones]

1. Rodgers
2. Brady
3. P. Manning
4. Brees
5. Big Ben
6. Eli
7.Romo
8.Ryan
9. Flacco
10 RG3/Russell Wilson

@ romo being ahead of Ryan

 

[cruzzz]

@ romo being ahead of Ryan

What makes you put Ryan over Romo? Unless your just basing it off last year.

 

[theswagofsweetjones]

What makes you put Ryan over Romo? Unless your just basing it off last year.

In case you haven't noticed Jaws list is based off of last season...and why wouldn't I put Ryan over romo...when was the last time cowboys made it to the playoffs with romo ? SitDown you been hating Ryan ever since he smacked up the giants with some payback

 

[100027]

Ryan had a GREAT year last season.  

 

[cruzzz]

In case you haven't noticed Jaws list is based off of last season...and why wouldn't I put Ryan over romo...when was the last time cowboys made it to the playoffs with romo ? SitDown you been hating Ryan ever since he smacked up the giants with some payback

My list was based on the last couple seasons and going into next year. And when it comes to winning they both have 1 playoff win so yeah. Also, trust me that "payback" has no bearing on my rankings 

 

[theswagofsweetjones]

My list was based on the last couple seasons and going into next year. And when it comes to winning they both have 1 playoff win so yeah. Also, trust me that "payback" has no bearing on my rankings 

Even still if your list is based off the past few seasons...romo shouldn't be ranked ahead of Ryan

 

[DeadsetAce]

Christian Ponder.

What about him?

 

[mez 0ne]

What makes Wilson better than RG3?

why not? Dude is a beast as well, arguments can be made for either.

 

[ny mavurs]

Luck, Wilson, and RGlll all had amazing seasons. Wouldn't be surprised if any of them win the Super Bowl within the next 3 years

 

[Hahahaha]

I don't think Ryan is bad but I think 6 is way too generous. As I said, he has Tony Gonzalez, Julio Jones and Roddy White.....life isn't too hard for him. He would be in my top 10 but I'm thinking 9 or 10.

How you sound "He has this guy and this guy and this guy" well who the hell he's suppose to have ? Todd pinkston ? Sit down

Matt Ryan has two WRs that are in the top 10, definitely top 15 WRs in the game. Tony Gonzalez is top 5 today and possibly the greatest TE of all time. Christian Ponder or Mark Sanchez in that situation, they'll be studs.

 

[theswagofsweetjones]

Matt Ryan has two WRs that are in the top 10, definitely top 15 WRs in the game. Tony Gonzalez is top 5 today and possibly the greatest TE of all time. Christian Ponder or Mark Sanchez in that situation, they'll be studs.

Yeah ? Because a QB isn't suppose to have weapons...sitcho *** down ...with your logic...all good QBs are throwing to players like Todd pinkston and peerless price to justify that they are good...hey tell your team to draft and sign better players

 

[Hahahaha]

Matt Ryan has two WRs that are in the top 10, definitely top 15 WRs in the game. Tony Gonzalez is top 5 today and possibly the greatest TE of all time. Christian Ponder or Mark Sanchez in that situation, they'll be studs.

Yeah ? Because a QB isn't suppose to have weapons...sitcho *** down ...with your logic...all good QBs are throwing to players like Todd pinkston and peerless price to justify that they are good...hey tell your team to draft and sign better players

 

[jpzx]

Christian Ponder.

 

[whoshotcha]

Christian Ponder.

Basically 

 

[ny mavurs]

Mark Sanchez has more playoff wins than Ryan and Romo combined

 

[dmxfury]

Ok....and...?

 

[mugzbo]

Ok....and...?

I think he forgot to mention that he'll also have the shortest career of the three as well. Mediocre QB talent and mediocre offensive coaching staff will do that to you. He's on the route to having a David Carr type career if he fails this year.

 

[651akathepaul]

I think Carr could have had a better career if he didn't get stuck on Houston for those inaugural years. His confidence and pocket presence were shot to hell from the start.