- 17,827
- 8,095
- Joined
- Jul 7, 2005
I find your argumentative points to be all over the place, but that's fine. All those points or facts about Brady vs. Peyton are correct, however the one main point that you didn't mention or failed to mention is that Brady has had a HOF coach by his side through all of that.Yeah, see you think you have me pegged, only you don't. I'm fine if you want to say Brady was one play away from one less SB. Bothers me none.Just go to back and revisit history with this old statement above CP1708, it's funny you wanna talk about Tom being one miracle play away form 4 rings, an undefeated season......yadda yadda yadda, but I'm almost sure you DON'T want to acknowledge that he had a miracle play go his way or in his favor to even begin his so called GOAT career with that tuck rule game against Oakland years prior. If you ever watched The Wire champ, you already know where I'm going with this one.........."You want it one way.........but it's the OTHER way"
The guy has been to 5 Super Bowls. Want to reduce it by 1? Go right ahead.
Still more SB wins than Peyton.
Still more appearances than Peyton.
Still a lesser roster of weapons than Peyton
Still more head to head wins vs Peyton
Still more playoff wins than Peyton
Still a better win % than Peyton
So by all means. If it means that much to you, pull the tuck rule game off his resume, cool by me.
I mean, the Giants won like 3 plays after the Tyree catch. The Raiders had an entire series still to finish the game, couldn't do it. Went to OT, still couldn't finish the game. But hey, one play.Almost the exact same scenario, but not close.
I say that because you were quick to mention that Brady had "a lesser roster of weapons than Peyton", and while that may be true let's not act like Brady hasn't had the luxury of having a mastermind calling the shots and pulling the strings on the sidelines his entire career. Let's just take that into account as well, that same mastermind that in a way helped Brady to achieve some of those very points that you were quick to throw against Peyton for not doing or not accomplishing.
As far as the Raiders having an entire series to finish the game, had the refs called that game and specific play correctly, the Raiders wouldn't have needed an extra series and the game would not have gone into OT from the get go.