It's because he now makes music some people don't like. You put his last 2 albums above Eminem Show. I think Recovery sucked and this album is eh. It's not blind Em hate it's opinion
10 million people think the complete opposite of you however.
Like I said, I love Eminem show. I still play a lot of it OFTEN on my bar's jukebox. Recovery got more spins within the last few years however. I like sober Eminem. A lot.
I'm not a super huge fan of SSLP. Its good, not great. Never have been since it was released when I was sophomore in HS. My favorite track on that was My Fault. lol.