- 744
- 10
yea, definitely let your orthopedist check that out. see if you can get measured too.Originally Posted by knightngale
Originally Posted by verynecessary
Originally Posted by JDB1523
JDB1523 wrote:
A bit of a sticky situation here if someone can help me out: been doing a lot of cardio lately and I've had some occasional lock-ups and soreness in my knee. Today I got through 45 minutes (planned on doing an hour) and had to stop because of it. My dad is a surgeon and my mom is a nurse, and they both said to keep off it for a few days, which I obviously agree with. However, I do cardio every day no questions asked, so what I was wondering was what might be a good alternative workout since I'll be doing other things the next few days. I'm still going to lift, but I was wondering: should I do circuit training? core exercises? just a regular lifting routine? I'm obviously planning no cardio, no plyometrics, no jump rope, etc.
Thanks in advance guys, let's just hope my knee gets better quickly and I don't have to have fluid taken out or a bigger surgery.
"what kind of cardio do you normally do? there are all sorts of things that can cause knee problems. try self-myofascial release (foam rolling) on the outer part of your thigh to loosen up your IT band. many people's knee problems are due to this. you could also have a strength imbalance in your quads (stronger on one side of your thigh than the other) or between your quads and hamstrings. you'd have to do lifts to target the weaker muscles. also, if you do a lot of running, try chi running. even if you have the "best" running shoes for your stride, heel strike and weak feet/ankles can cause problems all the way up your legs, spine, back, and neck.
one more thing you might want to do is get your legs accurately measured by a doctor. even a difference of a 1/4" can be murder on your joints if do a lot of long distance type exercise.
in the meantime, you can do boxing like was mentioned, or complexes/circuit training with some light-weight squats. you can also do tabata protocol."
Ok thanks a lot. I had been doing 40-60 minutes of cardio, but cut it back to 35 with HIIT, and always on the stationary bike or the elliptical. I tried running about 2 weeks ago, not even at a fast pace, and my right knee literally just LOCKED UP, felt like a bear trap came down on it. I know you mentioned it, but I don't think I'll be doing squats. I'm probably going to see an orthopedic doctor regardless just to be safe, but I'll Google what you've mentioned to see what I can come up with. And how do I quote using Safari?Still haven't figured that out. Edited w/Firefox...
one thing about stationary bike is you're more prone to develop muscular imbalances, medially/laterally on the same thigh, and between your quads and hamstrings on the same side. elliptical is a little better, but it's still possible.
if you do HIIT, you should be done after 20 minutes. generally, you go for higher intensity, shorter rest for the greater cardio and fat loss effects. this also minimizes the time spend doing it.
what about those 4 min. tabata training sessions? how many times a week for a noob?
tabata is good too. it can be more intense than HIIT, since the rest periods are so short, and it's harder to judge your effort if youdon't do "measured" exercises like sprints. so ppl do it once a week, if you're advanced, you can do 4 sets (16 min) in a day. it alldepends on your current conditioning/strength and what other workouts you do.
if you're a complete noob, and you're doing nothing else, you could probably do it 5 times a week if you're willing to push yourself and choose avariety of exercises (lifts, calisthenics, sprints, etc) so you don't wail on one muscle group too hard. for example, alternate upper and lower body.
i don't either, but at the same time, too much conditioning work is counterproductive for sports/athletics. once your conditioning level isup, you should be focused more on training for speed. if your goal is to burn off some fat, then by all means, 3x a week will get you there quick.Originally Posted by nealraj006
I don't see anything wrong with HIIT 3 times a week, as long as it's your main leg training. Sprinters could use it, but if you want mass, then stick to weights. I train legs with weights once a week at most, the rest is just sprints and calisthenics.
yea, when you're in a sport, training 5 or 6 days a week, your conditioning has to be there, so the sprints/intervals aren't so bad. doing 3x a week after a long period off (even a month) is masochisticOriginally Posted by keepzdasneakz
I guess the reason I don't perceive 1-2x a week as sufficient was because of my old tennis days in High school. We were running for about 2 hours 5 days a week, sometimes even on the weekend. This running is by far the most intense I've done as well, first 30 min was a warm up right with 1 min of sprinting at the end, then we would sprint across 4 tennis courts and back ...good days only about 6 times...bad days....I've counted up to 12 once with 45 sec breaks.Originally Posted by wj4
Doing HIIT 3-4 times a week is way too much. If you're doing it right, it can take up to 48 hours for a full recovery. I wouldn't do HIIT more than 3 times a week. If you're just starting out, I would go with one and work my way up to three.
It was intense for sure, but some of the fatter kids on my team went down 2 pant sizes in a month and I remember losing 10 lbs easily in just 3 weeks. Plus I would eat like a beast after I got home.