The Invincible Thread

[stillin729]

exactly. Over in the Cowboys thread dudes talking bout romo a first ballot hall of famer.. I just said nah..

I hate the Cowboys with a passion but like Romo as much as I can, he's not even a Hall of Famer due to lack of playoff success IMO

 

[Trey Bantz]

They need to put Kurt in the Hall man

 

[Chester McFloppy]

Romo is a really good QB who gets **** on unnecessarily but the thought of being first ballot is laughable.

 

[jjs07]

The NFL Clearly Has No Idea What Taunting Is


Goodell

Not to mention he plays for the racial slurs which makes it even more funny

I bet that made perfect sense to you when you clicked the "submit" button

 

[stillin729]

Kurt will make it

 

[kingkoopa]

Quote:

I hate the Cowboys with a passion but like Romo as much as I can, he's not even a Hall of Famer due to lack of playoff success IMO

Mostly no fault of his own IMO.

Between drunk Jerry and Wade Phillips, he never stood a chance.

 

[kingkoopa]

I bet that made perfect sense to you when you clicked the "submit" button

What doesn't make sense to you?

 

[stillin729]

Quote:


Mostly no fault of his own IMO.

Between drunk Jerry and Wade Phillips, he never stood a chance.

I can't argue there, Jerry trading for Roy Williams was a classic Jerry move

I also think McNabb will get in the hall regardless if I think he should be

 

[jjs07]

Kurt will make it

Agreed...he had a fantastic run, but winning a SB ring (MVP doesn't hurt either) changes the narrative completely.

 

[Deleted member 37754]

Chester's avy...

 

[jjs07]

I bet that made perfect sense to you when you clicked the "submit" button

What doesn't make sense to you?

We're talking 15 yard penalties, bruh.

False equivalency much?

 

[EddieDoyers]

Imagine Romo on a 90s Cowboys team

 

[rolaholic]

Imagine Romo on a 90s Cowboys team

Besides the rings,Romo > Aikman imo

 

[jjs07]

If we're making room in the hall for guys like McNabb, then Rivers/Romo are absolute locks.

Makes for an interesting debate. Especially if you lump in Eli. But he's got rings.

 

[Lovetohate3000]

Im a Cowboys fan and love Romo. Dude is appreciated after all those years we went looking for a decent QB after Aikman but he's always been in that 5 - 10 QB range in the l.
Getting rid of parcells was a huge mistake and detriment to Romos career as far as a winning stand point.

I don't think Romo is a hof either. Hall of very good. Romo is better then Aikman but rings and wins matter to voters.
I don't think McNabb belongs in the hof either. He's another hall of very good.

 

[Trey Bantz]

Yeah, I liked McNabb but nothing about him screams HoF

 

[gordyloc]

Im a Cowboys fan and love Romo. Dude is appreciated after all those years we went looking for a decent QB after Aikman but he's always been in that 5 - 10 QB range in the l.
Getting rid of parcells was a huge mistake and detriment to Romos career as far as a winning stand point.

I don't think Romo is a hof either. Hall of very good.

This!

 

[stillin729]

Yeah, I liked McNabb but nothing about him screams HoF

I think being one of the really good black QB's will def help his cause

I'd be happy to see him get in even if I think he's been a salty dude since his *** was traded to Washington

 

[Chester McFloppy]

Here's a good question for y'all (and no one get butthurt over the responses):

What's more important: peak or longevity? Would you take a player that had numerous MVP-level seasons and won a ring or two over someone who played sixteen seasons at a high level but never had success with awards/the postseason?

 

[Trey Bantz]

The Hall seems to want a combination of both.

Which is why peak guys like Eli and longevity guys like Rivers are considered fringe candidates.

Kurt was a peak guy and is having trouble getting in. I think his story (bagging groceries/arena football) gives him an extra push

 

[carver]

Give me the person who won a ring or two

 

[va757va]

The romo tier

Matt Ryan
Andy Dalton
Matt Stafford
Jay Cutler

So what tier is Eli in?

Cause rivers and romo >>>>> Eli when it comes to qb play...


Not team accomplishments where a phenomenal d-line gets overlooked for their heavy lifting during two sb runs...just plain one on one...player vs player, Eli is behind in every qb statstitic that matters...

 

[HNL HI]

Steelers don't have to leave their timezone the whole season. [emoji]129300[/emoji]

 

[va757va]

Here's a good question for y'all (and no one get butthurt over the responses):

What's more important: peak or longevity? Would you take a player that had numerous MVP-level seasons and won a ring or two over someone who played sixteen seasons at a high level but never had success with awards/the postseason?

Great question...TO checks both boxes and still is getting shafted...imagine that...

 

[stillin729]

Eli has two rings against the best coach and QB of all time

That puts him above anyone in that tier

TO is getting shafted because people hold a grudge which isn't fair but it's reality