Healthy Giannis would get my vote, and what Embiid has been doing the last few months is undeniable, but what’s the cherry picking with Jokic stats exactly?
He’s 25/12/10 on the #1 seed in the West and currently leading the league in-
TS%
PER (leader in this has won MVP many years in a row now)
Win Shares
Offensive Win Shares
Win Shares Per 48
Box Plus/Minus
Offensive Box Plus/Minus
Defensive Box Plus/Minus
Value Over Replacement Player
Defensive Rebound Percentage
Seems like that would be A LOT of cherry picking.
I can't argue his offensive stats. He's definitely up there with the all-time greats.
Anyone can argue about his advanced stats defensively, but at the end of the day, he's a cone on defence, players will constantly hunt for him and he will be subbed out for defensive possessions of close games. No idea why that's being ignored.
Then you talk about narratives, Zach Lowe (who is arguably the most influential media personality with MVP votes) is all in on Joker which is ironic because he said this a few years back: "Zach Lowe in 2019 on why he voted for Giannis as the MVP over Harden: "Giannis is not quite Harden as a scorer, or passer. He is unguardable. But the gap on offense, is not big enough to trump the gap on defense. Harden is a defensive liability even with the Rockets defensive scheme"
The goal post shifts to fit narratives which in the media space, is very important with influencing the votes.
Everyone is talking about how Denver is the #1 seed in the west, but guess what? Philly is half a game behind Denver in overall standings. Not to mention the top teams in the west is dealing with injuries (Zion when the Pels were #3, KD, LeBron, Curry etc...).
I'm too lazy to find the clips, but also the narrative of Joker never playing with an all star or all nba player over the years and still do this. I mean, technically, Embiid isn't playing with an all star this year either. And why are they talking about previous years in some scenarios and not others? Oh yeah, to fit the narratives.
On the last note, Value over replacement player: When Deandre Jordan is your replacement player, that's not a very impressive stat to look at.
Rant over. lol