I really don't see how a team can bring in top 25 classes consistently, and the main problem is recruiting. Sure, we're in a talent rich state, but we're also surrounded by UT, OU, and LSU...three of the premier programs in the country right now. Certainly you don't expect a !##! program like A&M to be able to out-recruit those three schools right now. It's gonna take developing players and winning footballs before we can even think about recruiting against those guys.
I really don't see how recruiting is the issue. You can get 2-star and 3-star kids and field a very competitive football team if you can develop kids. See Boise State, TCU, Utah, etc. Hell, TCU recruits primarily Texas, and they field one of the top two teams in the state. Is their success based on recruiting or development?
Fran had no clue how to recruit. He brought in some nice classes, but they were usually loaded at several positions while completely ignoring others (and it was the same positions being loaded or ignored every year). Mix that in with the complete lack of development (which I think is the biggest issue), and you get what you have now. A&M hasn't developed a player in far too long. Stephen McGee, Martellus Bennett, Mike Goodson, Von Miller (during Fran's time), Bradley Stephens, Derrick Stephens, Anthony Lewis, Jordan Pugh, Marquis Carpenter, Paul Freeney, Kellen Heard, Jorvorskie Lane, Howard Morrow...those are just the highly rated kids that Fran recruited that I could easily say were not significantly better when they left campus than they were when they got here. Fran did absolutely nothing to help those kids.
Compare that to Sherman and it's a completely different story (or so it seems). He's getting/got great production out of guys like Von Miller, Garrick Williams (2-star), Terrence Fredrick (2-star), Eddie Brown, Tony Jerod-Eddie, Howard Morrow, Jamie McCoy, Trent Hunter. He had Jordan Pugh playing a lot better than he did under Fran. He already has his young guys playing a lot better than any of Fran's young guys ever did.
I think firing RC Slocum the way we did put a curse on our program.