- 18,115
- 11,770
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2013
Adolph Reed, Jr., on reparations. Originally published back in 2000. I find his arguments largely persuasive and certainly relevant to today.
https://nonsite.org/editorial/the-case-against-reparations
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: this_feature_currently_requires_accessing_site_using_safari
Adolph Reed, Jr., on reparations. Originally published back in 2000. I find his arguments largely persuasive and certainly relevant to today.
https://nonsite.org/editorial/the-case-against-reparations
I don’t care about equality among all black people at this point...
Not just any reparations though, a cash pay out as a form of reparation would be divisive in the black community. It would be divisive amongst those who receive them as well because you’ll have an upper class sector of blacks who made their wealth without government intervention sharing access to amenities with those who did. The world, particularly the U.S. is operated off of the “Have’s and the Have Not’s”. You think over 75% of the America’s Black population becoming over night multi-millionaires is something that wouldn’t have ramifications??
and here we have a child of black immigrants admitting to why he's "for reparations" for ADOS, just not cash reparations like other marginalized groups have received from the US govt. he's resentful and jealous that he wouldn't be included. that's why he wants free education to be the extent of reparations due. thats why he bloviates about reparations being divisive and ados just wanting a handout from the white man and how giving money to a financially illiterate group is foolish.
it is because him and his African parents who immigrated over here would be excluded from these tangibles owed. ironically this is the same black immigrant son who liked the crabs in a barrel pic. but he's doing everything out of "concern", "good faith", and "unity" to try to limit the debt that society owes to ados. thats why I say lineage matters. we have black immigrants proclaiming to be allies for the cause but deep down they would hate to see you get paid. they revel themselves soon enough if you just let them keep on talking.
you don't see other white people speaking out against the cash reparations received by the jewish
you don't see other white people who think that they are entitled to the same reparations received by the jews just because the hue of their skin is the same.
you don't see other white people saying, "yeah the jews deserve reparations, I stand with them and their cause but lets just limit it to free education"
you don't see other white peoples saying the money received by jews is divisive.
you don't see other white people hinting at ramifications for being not receiving reparations like the jews.
hell, you don't see black immigrants doing any of the above to the jewish community receiving reparations
but notice their attitude and views towards the thought and idea of ados receiving cash payments as part of a plan of restitution for the forced, unpaid labor of their ancestors
then ask yourself are these people true allies. afterwards, inquiry why they are so insistent that you give your vote to the democrats, who promise specifics to illegal aliens and immigrants, but none to the descendants of the enslaved blacks who tragically built up the enormous wealth of this country without compensation
@deuce king .... #tangibles2020. no black agenda, no vote
we are not the same. our blood lines are different. mine suffered 400+ years of oppression. mine freely built up this country who's resources you enjoy. your parents decided to leave the motherland to move to a racist country led by black oppressing white supremacists for a bag. lineage matters. my people are fighters. yours fled, jumping out of the frying pan and into the fire in hopes of obtaining money, which you claim is of no importance.largofool why would I be jealous to see people that look like me and share the same plight as me win? Something that my potential future spouse and in theory my children could benefit from as well as my grandchildren and so on???
Lmfao You think the ~15 years of the Holocaust and the measly payout Jews got for it is even remotely comparable to 200+ years of slavery and 100+ years of oppression afterwards? White people arent the minority in this country, we as black people are. Their survival isn’t dependent on unity because they’ve made their generational ends. I’m invested in the survival of the black race in this country and that includes mental stimulation as well
You'e been brainwashed to think money is the end all path to freedom as opposed to knowledge especially knowledge of self, of our history our purpose which Black people in this country lack. But you just like many are a victim of the systematic mental retooling that white America has worked tirelessly to achieve. Going as far as to withhold your vote if you don’t get serious consideration for your reparation wants. The same rights that the ancestors died for, you’re looking to abuse unless you profit off of what they endured
This thread is toxic at this point.
I’m sure this will be ignored
But I said it before if someone is telling a black person not to vote they are working on behalf of white supremacy whether they want to own it or not
Seems like they might be owning it tho
we are not the same. our blood lines are different. mine suffered 400+ years of oppression. mine freely built up this country who's resources you enjoy. your parents decided to leave the motherland to move to a racist country led by black oppressing white supremacists for a bag. lineage matters. my people are fighters. yours fled, jumping out of the frying pan and into the fire in hopes of obtaining money, which you claim is of no importance.
im not entirely certain of the root of your jealousy but I suspect it stems from knowing that you aren't entitled to the reparations due to ADOS and you feel leftout. your sense of obligation to the resources my ancestors died for are baffling. also you I'm sure you were teased growing up. that's probably the base of your resentment
you think the jews being "measly" compensated for the atrocities committed against their people had no effect on the amount of wealth they accumulate or the industries they lead today. you think the effects of this "measly" payout wasn't transformative to the families who lost everything during the holocaust. The jews are indeed a minority and their survival is because of their unity. so unite with ados and support cash reparations because it would close the wealth gap which is responsible for many of the black community's ills. you can't truly be invested in the survival of ados if you only champion free education while arbitrarily denying the money owed. stop acting like its a choice when you can support both. but again your black immigrant parents left a black county for the white mans money. thats why im not surprised that you echo the white mans position in denying what's owed to ados
This is where the line will be drawn. I will not be lectured by a 1st generation America born to black immigrants from Ghana about freedom, independence, and the history of blacks in America. money is in fact the path to freedom in a capitalistic society. Your black immigrant parents abandoned their roots in their homeland to move to a racist white country for what? to be educated by the white man, in hopes that the white man provides an opportunity to obtain some of the white mans money. we're all victims, difference is your parents choose this life for you. im born of strong blacks who didn't flee their own land and people to run to the oppressive white man's. lineage matters. I'm a descendant of fighters. thats why I'll never disrespect them. they suffered for me to have the right to vote, not for me to give it away with nothing promised in return.
@deuce king ..... #tangibles2020. no black agenda, no vote
we are not the same. our blood lines are different. mine suffered 400+ years of oppression. mine freely built up this country who's resources you enjoy. your parents decided to leave the motherland to move to a racist country led by black oppressing white supremacists for a bag. lineage matters. my people are fighters. yours fled, jumping out of the frying pan and into the fire in hopes of obtaining money, which you claim is of no importance.
im not entirely certain of the root of your jealousy but I suspect it stems from knowing that you aren't entitled to the reparations due to ADOS and you feel leftout. your sense of obligation to the resources my ancestors died for are baffling. also you I'm sure you were teased growing up. that's probably the base of your resentment
you think the jews being "measly" compensated for the atrocities committed against their people had no effect on the amount of wealth they accumulate or the industries they lead today. you think the effects of this "measly" payout wasn't transformative to the families who lost everything during the holocaust. The jews are indeed a minority and their survival is because of their unity. so unite with ados and support cash reparations because it would close the wealth gap which is responsible for many of the black community's ills. you can't truly be invested in the survival of ados if you only champion free education while arbitrarily denying the money owed. stop acting like its a choice when you can support both. but again your black immigrant parents left a black county for the white mans money. thats why im not surprised that you echo the white mans position in denying what's owed to ados
This is where the line will be drawn. I will not be lectured by a 1st generation America born to black immigrants from Ghana about freedom, independence, and the history of blacks in America. money is in fact the path to freedom in a capitalistic society. Your black immigrant parents abandoned their roots in their homeland to move to a racist white country for what? to be educated by the white man, in hopes that the white man provides an opportunity to obtain some of the white mans money. we're all victims, difference is your parents choose this life for you. im born of strong blacks who didn't flee their own land and people to run to the oppressive white man's. lineage matters. I'm a descendant of fighters. thats why I'll never disrespect them. they suffered for me to have the right to vote, not for me to give it away with nothing promised in return.
@deuce king ..... #tangibles2020. no black agenda, no vote
Black Americans face a unique uphill battle that no other people in America face. They are the only ones that have had systemic inequality built into the very fabric of their lives. Most other people are descendants of people that came here by choice and for an opportunity for a better life for future generations.