- Jul 2, 2001
- 24,020
- 3,135
Got this from a LOST chat...not a spoiler just speculation. Makes sense right? I guess I just didn't think about it that way on the spot.
Dan had to die because while he was in Ann Arbor, he figured out a way to change the past, but the Others are enforcing WHAT HAPPENED HAPPENED. Dan died to keep WHH in line. Young Eloise saw Dan die (presumably) so future old Eloise, when she sends Dan to the island, using the healing capabilities as bait, knows she is sending him to his death, because she already saw him die.