- 23,318
- 11,740
I agree that you shouldn't judge him based on his pre-LeBron days as that team was straight garbage.
BUT there were signs that shows he is not the best #1 option out there. Dude get's tunnel visioned, plays no defence, questionable leadership attributes and now will be seen as prioritizing being the "man" over winning. Joe Johnson, Bledsoe, Reggie Jackson Melo, Butler and many other players chose this path and a 2nd round exit, while not being close to a contender, was the best they could do.
You could argue that Beard was an exception but actually wanted to stay, the money just didn't work out.
In order for a Kyrie lead team to be somewhat successful, they need to construct a team similar to the 01 Philly team or today's Boston team. Both very hard to do.
The issue with Kyrie has nothing to do with the team before LeBron, like you said.
You can watch him the past couple of seasons when LeBron's on the bench, and see his propensity for going into iso after iso. LeBron is the glue that keeps the ball moving and holds the team together. I'm not sure that Kyrie has the court vision to be "the guy" on a winning team.