- Sep 28, 2020
- 1,395
- 2,978
And if you rephrase "Michael Jordan is the greatest basketball player of all time" to "Pete Maravich is the greatest basketball player of all time", Ben Shapiro would drag out his footstool and shake your hand.
My intent in that joke wasn't to clown you. That said, I got your point and agree with it.
If you'll forgive a bit of a narcissistic aside... I think one difference between us is I'm not super focused on fairness when I discuss things with other people. I mean, I have my sense of what is fair and I use that as a compass, but I find that most people aren't very interested in what I find fair. So either conversation goes nowhere or I find myself painfully trying to cram my vision into their ethical framework which I'm simultaneously guessing at. Instead, what I do think and talk about more is suffering - especially suffering that serves no end that I find valuable. Since I'm new here, I want to be clear: I think white supremacy is the cause of a tremendous amount of suffering and serves no end that I can see any value in.
I have a mother who constantly reminds me that life isn't fair. This wasn't so I'd adopt a fatalistic cynicism: she encouraged me to advocate and act for justice. She did this so I'd understand and be comfortable that despite my best efforts, the world would remain unfair. Despair is a hell of a drug.
The clear caveat is that if Person A has $1 and Person B has $2, giving them each one dollar hasn't changed the absolute difference between the two - but it would change the relative difference.
I had a very similar reductive example all typed out and then thought, he'll tear through this like a bull through paper. Still, I think the example illustrates the idea of different measures of inequality. Here with two people it's relative vs. absolute, but in the more complex scenario of our society the number of reasonable measures is something like unbounded. I'm sure we agree that balancing between these notions can be tricky.
Anyway, I'm 100% on everything else you typed: Retribution is necessary, class doesn't cover all inequality, the judiciary is a mess and might be the worst legacy of the last 4 years, and calling debt relief socialism is internalizing Republican rhetoric. I look forward to barely disagreeing with you more.