Oh I'm sorry, Did I Break Your Conversation........Well Allow Me A Movie Thread by S&T

[johnnyredstorm]

Originally Posted by MrONegative

Shosanna Dreyfus by Melanie Laurent for Inglourious Basterds

Thought about taking her

 

[jpzx]

I really like the Melanie Laurent pick, and I was thinking of taking Walter from The Big Lebowski a few rounds ago.

 

[noskey]

Originally Posted by JohnnyRedStorm

Originally Posted by MrONegative

Shosanna Dreyfus by Melanie Laurent for Inglourious Basterds

Thought about taking her

So did I (Melanie Laurent is

), but I didnt feel like she made enough of an impact as a character relative to the women who were still on the board.


So we done? Ready to vote?

 

[mronegative]

Originally Posted by Noskey

Originally Posted by JohnnyRedStorm

Originally Posted by MrONegative

Shosanna Dreyfus by Melanie Laurent for Inglourious Basterds

Thought about taking her

So did I (Melanie Laurent is

), but I didnt feel like she made enough of an impact as a character relative to the women who were still on the board.


So we done? Ready to vote?

It was between her, Alabama from True Romance and Catwoman from Batman Returns...

We shoulda done by decade

Yea we done.

 

[jpzx]

Did anyone take Jackie Brown?

I just watched that by the way.

 

[noskey]

No one took her.

Jackie Brown is pretty good. It's overshadowed by almost all other QT films and it's forgotten a lot when QT is brought up, so I'm not surprised no one took her.

 

[johnnyredstorm]

Alabama was another one I thought about taking just for that beating she took by Tony Soprano

Love Jackie Brown, did a powerpoint on that film for my Sexism class last year.

 

[jpzx]

Samuel Jackson in Jackie Brown 

Felt like Jules. Holy %!*@ that hair and goatee though.

Bomont

 

[CP1708]

MrO
Director --- Quentin Tarantino, Pulp Fiction
Leading Man --- Patrick Bateman, American Psycho - Christian Bale
Comedic Role ---Borat, Borat - Sacha Baron Cohen
Kick @#$ Chick --- Shosanna Dreyfus, Inglourious Basterds - Melanie Laurent
Leading Lady --- Beatrix Kiddo, Kill Bill - Uma Thurmon
Action Hero-Super Hero --- Terminator, Terminator 2 - Arnold Schwarzenegger
Dramatic Male --- Oh Deu-Su, Oldboy - Min-Sik Choi
Glue Guy, Character Guy --- Jules Winnfield, Pulp Fiction - Samuel L Jackson
Villian Role --- Agent Smith, The Matrix - Hugo Weaving
Utility Role --- Edward Scissorhands, Edward Scissorhands - Johnny Depp

Noskey
Director --- Martin Scorsese, Goodfellas.
Leading Man --- Forrest Gump, Forrest Gump - Tom Hanks
Comedic Role --- Alan, The Hangover - Zach Galifianakis
Kick @#$ Chick --- Trinity, The Matrix - Carrie Anne Moss
Leading Lady --- Clarice Starling, The Silence of the Lambs - Jodie Foster
Action Hero-Super Hero --- Neo, The Matrix - Keanu Reeves
Dramatic Male --- Lester Burnham, American Beauty - Kevin Spacey
Glue Guy, Character Guy --- Begbie, Trainspotting - Robert Carlyle
Villian Role --- Mr Blonde, Reservoir Dogz - Michael Madsen
Utility Role --- Walter Sobchak, The Big Lebowski - John Goodman

Big J
Director --- Steven Spielberg, Schindler's List
Leading Man --- Malcolm X, Malcolm X - Denzel Washington
Comedic Role --- Andy Stitzer, The 40 Year Old Virgin - Steve Carell
Kick @#$ Chick --- Lara Croft, Tomb Raider - Angelina Jolie
Leading Lady --- Editth Piaf, La Vie en Rose - Marion Cotillard
Action Hero-Super Hero --- Iron Man, Iron Man - Robert Downey Jr
Dramatic Male --- Andrew Beckett, Philadelphia - Tom Hanks
Glue Guy, Character Guy --- Bullet Tooth Tony, Snatch - Vinnie Jones
Villian Role --- Dainel Plainview, There Will Be Blood - Daniel Day Lewis
Utility Role --- Bob Harris, Lost in Translation - Bill Murray

Dub
Director --- Stanley Kubrick, Eyes Wide Shut
Leading Man --- George Jung, Blow, Johnny Depp
Comedic Role --- Stifler, American Pie - Seann William Scott
Kick @#$ Chick --- Leeloo, The Fifth Element - Milla Jolovich
Leading Lady --- Annie Wilkes, Misery - Kathy Bates
Action Hero-Super Hero --- John McClane, Die Hard With a Vengeance - Bruce Willis
Dramatic Male --- Leon, The Professional - Jean Reno
Glue Guy, Character Guy --- Paul Sunday, There Will Be Blood - Paul Dano
Villian Role --- The Joker, The Dark Knight - Heath Ledger
Utility Role --- Silent Bob, Chasing Amy - Kevin Smith

JPZ
Director --- Christopher Nolan, The Dark Knight
Leading Man ---Andy Dufrense, The Shawkshank Redemption - Tim Robbins
Comedic Role --- Phil Connors, Groundhog Day - Bill Murray
Kick @#$ Chick --- Fox, Wanted, Angelina Jolie
Leading Lady --- Nina Sayers, Black Swan, Natalie Portman
Action Hero-Super Hero --- Darth Maul, Star Wars I, The Phantom Menace - Ray Park
Dramatic Male --- Jack Dawson, Titanic - Leonardo DiCaprio
Glue Guy, Character Guy --- Col Hans Landa, Inglourious Basterds - Christoph Waltz
Villian Role --- Anton Chigurh, No Country for Old Men - Javier Bardem
Utility Role --- McLovin, Superbad - Christopher Mintz-Plasse

Chester
Director --- Peter Jackson, The Lord of the Rings, Return of the King
Leading Man ---  Maximus Decimus Meridius, Gladiator - Russell Crowe
Comedic Role --- Shaun, Shaun of the Dead - Simon Pegg
Kick @#$ Chick --- Lisbeth Salander, The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, Noomi Rapace
Leading Lady --- Maggie Fitzgerald, Million Dollar Baby - Hilary Swank
Action Hero-Super Hero --- V, V for Vendetta - Hugo Weaving
Dramatic Male --- William Wallace, Braveheart, Mel Gibson
Glue Guy, Character Guy --- Captain Jack Sparrow,  Pirates of the Carribean - Johnny Depp
Villian Role --- Hannibal Lecter, The Silence of the Lambs - Anthony Hopkins
Utility Role --- William Cutting, Gangs of New York - Daniel Day Lewis

CP
Director --- Robert Zemekis, Forrest Gump
Leading Man --- Neil McCauley, Heat - Robert DeNiro
Comedic Role --- Austin Powers, Austin Powers - Mike Myers
Kick @#$ Chick --- Sarah Conner, Terminator 2 - Linda Hamilton
Leading Lady --- Erin Brockovich, Erin Brockovich, Julia Roberts
Action Hero-Super Hero --- Jason Bourne, The Bourne Identity - Matt Damon
Dramatic Male --- Kaiser Sose, The Usual Suspects - Kevin Spacey
Glue Guy, Character Guy --- Teddy KGB, Rounders, John Malkovich
Villian Role --- Alonzo Harris, Training Day - Denzel Washington
Utility Role --- Samuel Gerard, The Fugitive - Tommy Lee Jones

Johnny
Director --- David Fincher, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Leading Man --- Derek Vinyard, American History X - Ed Norton
Comedic Role ---Jeffrey Lebowski, The Big Lebowski, Jeff Bridges
Kick @#$ Chick --- Cherry Darling, Planet Terror - Rose McGowan
Leading Lady --- Christine Collins, Changeling - Angelina Jolie
Action Hero-Super Hero --- King Leonidas, 300 - Gerard Butler
Dramatic Male --- Will Hunting, Good Will Hunting - Matt Damon
Glue Guy, Character Guy --- David Wooderson, Dazed and Confused - Mathew McConaughey
Villian Role --- Tyler Durden, Fight Club - Brad Pitt
Utility Role --- Winston Wolfe, Pulp Fiction, Harvey Keitel


Voting begins, I will PM guys as I need to find them, but if you want to vote, please send your votes to me in PM.  If you want to just vote in here, you can. 

Owners, you need to vote too. 

 

[johnnyredstorm]

Chris Tucker was perfect as Beaumont, hell, I shoulda picked him as my glue guy. Those 3 minutes of screen time were lulz.

 

[mronegative]

If I knew no one was gonna take the Coen bros, I woulda went Chigurh first pick

Shoulda had a mascot/animated char slot too. Woulda took Simba or Cartman or Wilson from Cast Away

and damn...hit girl and joaquin from gladiator didn't get took either?

 

[kevin cleveland]

No Juno or Ron Burgandy.

I'll send CP my top three soon.

 

[jpzx]

Since Tuesday night I have watched:

Eternal Sunshine Of A Spotless Mind
Black Swan
We Were Soldiers
Mission: Impossible
Jackie Brown
A Bronx Tale

Making moves.

 

[johnnyredstorm]

I forgot all about Ellen Page.

 

[big j 33]

Sent my top 3 in.

I must say this was one of the harder drafts to grade that we've done. Everyone had a character I thought was the best (or at least top 2-3), so I'm impressed with everyone overall.

 

[kevin cleveland]

Whoops. Forgot. Give me a second.

 

[kevin cleveland]

Voted.

It really was tough. I thought I would be able to eyeball it, but I had to come up with a point system and !+%*.

 

[CP1708]

AHS this week was legit. 

  Love that angle.  It leads me to think they are in fact going to do what they set out too. They have a built in way to keep cast members, without keeping cast members.  That won't work forever, but a couple seasons could be squeezed out of this. 

Good job with the votes so far, I think I already have more for this one then I did the last draft and it's only been 24 hours, and with everyone preoccupied with other dealings and what not.  Great work. 

I still want to track down a couple other guys that have been in here, they deserve to have some input. 

 

[noskey]

Originally Posted by Big J 33

I must say this was one of the harder drafts to grade that we've done. Everyone had a character I thought was the best (or at least top 2-3), so I'm impressed with everyone overall.

Yep. It was tough to figure out how I wanted to rank everyone down the last spot.

 

[mronegative]

Originally Posted by Kevin Cleveland

Voted.

It really was tough. I thought I would be able to eyeball it, but I had to come up with a point system and !+%*.

I might have to do that. I thought this would be simple

 

[noskey]

Originally Posted by CP1708

AHS this week was legit. 

  Love that angle.  It leads me to think they are in fact going to do what they set out too. They have a built in way to keep cast members, without keeping cast members.  That won't work forever, but a couple seasons could be squeezed out of this.

Man that $%*$ was CRAZY. Did not expect that to happen ever. At this point I wouldnt be surprised if there was a new family moving in next year...

 

[illmaticsoulchild]

If you copy and paste (paste special, as: text) the lines below in excel, it will put selections in columns by OWNER, CATEGORY, PICK, RANK. Makes ranking much easier.

OWNERCATEGORYPICKRANK

Big JAction Hero-Super HeroIron Man, Iron Man - Robert Downey Jr0

Big JComedic RoleAndy Stitzer, The 40 Year Old Virgin - Steve Carell0

Big JDirectorSteven Spielberg, Schindler's List0

Big JDramatic MaleAndrew Beckett, Philadelphia - Tom Hanks0

Big JGlue Guy, Character GuyBullet Tooth Tony, Snatch - Vinnie Jones0

Big JKick @#$ ChickLara Croft, Tomb Raider - Angelina Jolie0

Big JLeading LadyEditth Piaf, La Vie en Rose - Marion Cotillard0

Big JLeading ManMalcolm X, Malcolm X - Denzel Washington0

Big JUtility RoleBob Harris, Lost in Translation - Bill Murray0

Big JVillian RoleDainel Plainview, There Will Be Blood - Daniel Day Lewis0

ChesterAction Hero-Super HeroV, V for Vendetta - Hugo Weaving0

ChesterComedic RoleShaun, Shaun of the Dead - Simon Pegg0

ChesterDirectorPeter Jackson, The Lord of the Rings, Return of the King0

ChesterDramatic MaleWilliam Wallace, Braveheart, Mel Gibson0

ChesterGlue Guy, Character GuyCaptain Jack Sparrow,  Pirates of the Carribean - Johnny Depp0

ChesterKick @#$ ChickLisbeth Salander, The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, Noomi Rapace0

ChesterLeading LadyMaggie Fitzgerald, Million Dollar Baby - Hilary Swank0

ChesterLeading Man Maximus Decimus Meridius, Gladiator - Russell Crowe0

ChesterUtility RoleWilliam Cutting, Gangs of New York - Daniel Day Lewis0

ChesterVillian RoleHannibal Lecter, The Silence of the Lambs - Anthony Hopkins0

CPAction Hero-Super HeroJason Bourne, The Bourne Identity - Matt Damon0

CPComedic RoleAustin Powers, Austin Powers - Mike Myers0

CPDirectorRobert Zemekis, Forrest Gump0

CPDramatic MaleKaiser Sose, The Usual Suspects - Kevin Spacey0

CPGlue Guy, Character GuyTeddy KGB, Rounders, John Malkovich0

CPKick @#$ ChickSarah Conner, Terminator 2 - Linda Hamilton0

CPLeading LadyErin Brockovich, Erin Brockovich, Julia Roberts0

CPLeading ManNeil McCauley, Heat - Robert DeNiro0

CPUtility RoleSamuel Gerard, The Fugitive - Tommy Lee Jones0

CPVillian RoleAlonzo Harris, Training Day - Denzel Washington0

DubAction Hero-Super HeroJohn McClane, Die Hard With a Vengeance - Bruce Willis0

DubComedic RoleStifler, American Pie - Seann William Scott0

DubDirectorStanley Kubrick, Eyes Wide Shut0

DubDramatic MaleLeon, The Professional - Jean Reno0

DubGlue Guy, Character GuyPaul Sunday, There Will Be Blood - Paul Dano0

DubKick @#$ ChickLeeloo, The Fifth Element - Milla Jolovich0

DubLeading LadyAnnie Wilkes, Misery - Kathy Bates0

DubLeading ManGeorge Jung, Blow, Johnny Depp0

DubUtility RoleSilent Bob, Chasing Amy - Kevin Smith0

DubVillian RoleThe Joker, The Dark Knight - Heath Ledger0

JohnnyAction Hero-Super HeroKing Leonidas, 300 - Gerard Butler0

JohnnyComedic RoleJeffrey Lebowski, The Big Lebowski, Jeff Bridges0

JohnnyDirectorDavid Fincher, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button0

JohnnyDramatic MaleWill Hunting, Good Will Hunting - Matt Damon0

JohnnyGlue Guy, Character GuyDavid Wooderson, Dazed and Confused - Mathew McConaughey0

JohnnyKick @#$ ChickCherry Darling, Planet Terror - Rose McGowan0

JohnnyLeading LadyChristine Collins, Changeling - Angelina Jolie0

JohnnyLeading ManDerek Vinyard, American History X - Ed Norton0

JohnnyUtility RoleWinston Wolfe, Pulp Fiction, Harvey Keitel0

JohnnyVillian RoleTyler Durden, Fight Club - Brad Pitt0

JPZAction Hero-Super HeroDarth Maul, Star Wars I, The Phantom Menace - Ray Park0

JPZComedic RolePhil Connors, Groundhog Day - Bill Murray0

JPZDirectorChristopher Nolan, The Dark Knight0

JPZDramatic MaleJack Dawson, Titanic - Leonardo DiCaprio0

JPZGlue Guy, Character GuyCol Hans Landa, Inglourious Basterds - Christoph Waltz0

JPZKick @#$ ChickFox, Wanted, Angelina Jolie0

JPZLeading LadyNina Sayers, Black Swan, Natalie Portman0

JPZLeading ManAndy Dufrense, The Shawkshank Redemption - Tim Robbins0

JPZUtility RoleMcLovin, Superbad - Christopher Mintz-Plasse0

JPZVillian RoleAnton Chigurh, No Country for Old Men - Javier Bardem0

MrOAction Hero-Super HeroTerminator, Terminator 2 - Arnold Schwarzenegger0

MrOComedic RoleBorat, Borat - Sacha Baron Cohen0

MrODirectorQuentin Tarantino, Pulp Fiction0

MrODramatic MaleOh Deu-Su, Oldboy - Min-Sik Choi0

MrOGlue Guy, Character GuyJules Winnfield, Pulp Fiction - Samuel L Jackson0

MrOKick @#$ ChickShosanna Dreyfus, Inglourious Basterds - Melanie Laurent0

MrOLeading LadyBeatrix Kiddo, Kill Bill - Uma Thurmon0

MrOLeading ManPatrick Bateman, American Psycho - Christian Bale0

MrOUtility RoleEdward Scissorhands, Edward Scissorhands - Johnny Depp0

MrOVillian RoleAgent Smith, The Matrix - Hugo Weaving0

NoskeyAction Hero-Super HeroNeo, The Matrix - Keanu Reeves0

NoskeyComedic RoleAlan, The Hangover - Zach Galifianakis0

NoskeyDirectorMartin Scorsese, Goodfellas.0

NoskeyDramatic MaleLester Burnham, American Beauty - Kevin Spacey0

NoskeyGlue Guy, Character GuyBegbie, Trainspotting - Robert Carlyle0

NoskeyKick @#$ ChickTrinity, The Matrix - Carrie Anne Moss0

NoskeyLeading LadyClarice Starling, The Silence of the Lambs - Jodie Foster0

NoskeyLeading ManForrest Gump, Forrest Gump - Tom Hanks0

NoskeyUtility RoleWalter Sobchak, The Big Lebowski - John Goodman0

NoskeyVillian RoleMr Blonde, Reservoir Dogz - Michael Madsen0

 

[big j 33]

Time to create a formula so complex it will make the BCS look like elementary school math.

 

[illmaticsoulchild]

BTW, just sort by category, then place your rank (3-10 scale, 10 best).
Then resort by owner again and sum the rank totals.

 

[johnnyredstorm]

I just went with the eye test.