- 13,868
- 44
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2008
so are you saying that all muslim are terrorist? because terrorist do "in the name of Allah"...Originally Posted by Boys Noize
Originally Posted by UnkleTomCruze
Originally Posted by Boys Noize
I was reading about the Elizabeth Smart kidnapping case recently and I thought, why aren't more religious people considered insane? Here we have a guy claiming to be the prophet of god, promised 49 wives, and he's going around kidnapping kids and raping them under the guise of religion. Is it taboo to claim that religious people are delusional to the point of mental defect? Where do you draw the line between someone hearing the "voice of god" commanding them to build houses in Uganda and someone hearing "the voice of god" commanding them to attack Americans? One might be for good and one might be for evil but aren't both equally crazy?
I understand not all religious people are "extreme" but the idea of any religion is that you place your belief in something that cannot be proven right? If a child believed in Santa, it would be considered cute. If a grown man still put out milk and cookies every December 24th, he would be considered crazy right? I guess the point I'm trying to get across is, at what point are people considered insane? What is the difference between the guy rambling about god on the corner of the street and your neighborhood pastor?
Please don't humor OP. Dude/Dudette is clearly in the mood for a religion bashing seminar.
OP, you're obviously smart enough to acknowledge that the individual that committed these crimes, and in the source and inspiration from which this thread sprouted from, was ACTING UNDER THE GUISE OF RELIGION. Which means, he was using a religion as FRONT/FACADE/SMOKESCREEN (these are all words that are synonymous with guise) to justify his innate evil. Which in turn means that the man himself was inherently rotting, and it was not "religion" that made him do what he did. That being the case, why the hate for religion and/or those who choose to be religious? It's quite naive of you, and your logic is facile, when you choose to demonize an entire "complex" because of one nutjob who falsely claims to be acting in the name of God. The fact that you've actually convinced yourself of otherwise makes me question your sanity. "Yes, because this crazy guy said God ordered this man to rape and murder lil children, which he did, God and/or His and/or practitioners of His religion must be crazy. Let's completely disregard the obviously maniacle mentality of the individual who actually committed this crime..."...
I guess I'm completely logical and justified in believing that all atheists are nuts when one of y'all murders and rapes. I guess it's not the individual that should be held accountable for his or her actions, but rather the "complex" that said individual claims to be affiliated with. Right?
You religion bashers honestly make me cringe.
I honestly feel like I sound like a broken record. Again, I'm not singling out any one instance as to why I believe religion to be a delusion, rather, I'm pointing out this one specific case because it was what I was reading at the time.
The question I keep posing is why when someone does something evil, according to our societies norms, because "god told him to do it" that he is insane but when someone does something good, according to our societies norms, because "god told him to do it" that he is normal? A man could volunteer at homeless shelters on his weekends, donate half his salary to fighting famine in Africa, and judge the Wednesday night bingo games at the senior center, but I'd still consider him insane if he does all of the above because an invisible force compelled him to do it. Of course we could go deeper down the rabbit hole and question the fact that since there are so many different religions in this world could it be that ALL of them are wrong? And don't believers in each religion think that believers of the other religions are delusional too? When we talk about people starting wars and killing each other because of a difference in belief in unquantifiable things, we clearly see the divide between those who believe and those who don't. Atheists/agnostics are not going to bomb a mosque or a synagogue. You can lay the blame solely on individuals but can you honestly say that religion doesn't play ANY part in pushing that behavior?
I also disagree with your use of "innate evil" and "inherently rotting". Those are YOUR religious beliefs, let's not thrust those upon everyone alright? I believe the man is insane but I don't think he was born evil.
Plus it is not a teaching in any religion to do evil.
Every religion has its own believe but I dont think God has ever told anything to anyone personally.