- 11,939
- 11
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2009
I'm going to start ignoring people who don't have certain users on ignore. IGNORE THE IDIOTS.
Amar'e Stoudemire is overrated.
- Thread in 'Sports & Training' Thread starter Started by allreds,
- Start date
- 4,837
- 215
- Joined
- Apr 22, 2010
Originally Posted by E3LAL
Even when he was with the Suns, he was overrated. All he did was shoot midrange jumpers and I don't even know if he has a post game. Nash was to Amare as Kidd was to Kmart. It is a shame that a guy with his size and strength is not a defensive presence.
Sidenote, Bosh said he wanted to be on national TV more to shop people how great he was...how's that going
Who the hell do you guys listen to say that Amar'e is overrated? Who even rated him? I don't get it, I never heard anyone call Amar'e an "elite" PF or said he's worth a max deal.
- 4,837
- 215
- Joined
- Apr 22, 2010
Originally Posted by E3LAL
Even when he was with the Suns, he was overrated. All he did was shoot midrange jumpers and I don't even know if he has a post game. Nash was to Amare as Kidd was to Kmart. It is a shame that a guy with his size and strength is not a defensive presence.
Sidenote, Bosh said he wanted to be on national TV more to shop people how great he was...how's that going
Who the hell do you guys listen to say that Amar'e is overrated? Who even rated him? I don't get it, I never heard anyone call Amar'e an "elite" PF or said he's worth a max deal.
- 4,991
- 454
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2004
1. Amar'e > Bosh
2. Amar'e won ROY, with Starbury running the team
3. Nash is hands down one of the best point guards ever.
4. You are going to over pay in the FA market no matter what, unless you sign one of the top 5 players in the league.
5. Amar'e isn't going to do it alone, just like MJ & Kobe never did.
6. Yes, he should be a better defender and rebounder for his size and strength
7. I honestly believe he has never been truly educated on the game. He was playing on raw athleticism before he hurt his leg. Now he has a jump shot.
8. Welcome2Jungle has to be in HS. 1st Mike Brown is a top flight coach and now Nash is overrated
9. ...
10. ..
2. Amar'e won ROY, with Starbury running the team
3. Nash is hands down one of the best point guards ever.
4. You are going to over pay in the FA market no matter what, unless you sign one of the top 5 players in the league.
5. Amar'e isn't going to do it alone, just like MJ & Kobe never did.
6. Yes, he should be a better defender and rebounder for his size and strength
7. I honestly believe he has never been truly educated on the game. He was playing on raw athleticism before he hurt his leg. Now he has a jump shot.
8. Welcome2Jungle has to be in HS. 1st Mike Brown is a top flight coach and now Nash is overrated
9. ...
10. ..
- 4,991
- 454
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2004
1. Amar'e > Bosh
2. Amar'e won ROY, with Starbury running the team
3. Nash is hands down one of the best point guards ever.
4. You are going to over pay in the FA market no matter what, unless you sign one of the top 5 players in the league.
5. Amar'e isn't going to do it alone, just like MJ & Kobe never did.
6. Yes, he should be a better defender and rebounder for his size and strength
7. I honestly believe he has never been truly educated on the game. He was playing on raw athleticism before he hurt his leg. Now he has a jump shot.
8. Welcome2Jungle has to be in HS. 1st Mike Brown is a top flight coach and now Nash is overrated
9. ...
10. ..
2. Amar'e won ROY, with Starbury running the team
3. Nash is hands down one of the best point guards ever.
4. You are going to over pay in the FA market no matter what, unless you sign one of the top 5 players in the league.
5. Amar'e isn't going to do it alone, just like MJ & Kobe never did.
6. Yes, he should be a better defender and rebounder for his size and strength
7. I honestly believe he has never been truly educated on the game. He was playing on raw athleticism before he hurt his leg. Now he has a jump shot.
8. Welcome2Jungle has to be in HS. 1st Mike Brown is a top flight coach and now Nash is overrated
9. ...
10. ..
shoegallery
Banned
- 790
- 10
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2009
bosh > amare .
Bosh just doesnt have the fit in miami yet . He got this though by Jan .
Bosh just doesnt have the fit in miami yet . He got this though by Jan .
shoegallery
Banned
- 790
- 10
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2009
bosh > amare .
Bosh just doesnt have the fit in miami yet . He got this though by Jan .
Bosh just doesnt have the fit in miami yet . He got this though by Jan .
- 7,084
- 45
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2007
People are jumping on the Bosh bandwagon cuz he's on Miami huh?!
It's really 1A/B IMO.
Offensively, Bosh aint ever coming close to Stat. That's just me. Amare has far more range, a better midrange game, as well as more of a post game. Bosh? Ehh.
However, Bosh definitely puts a lot more effort defensively, which is why i'd give him the nod over Amare. However, Stat isnt exactly a poor defender, he just has no effort.
It's really 1A/B IMO.
Offensively, Bosh aint ever coming close to Stat. That's just me. Amare has far more range, a better midrange game, as well as more of a post game. Bosh? Ehh.
However, Bosh definitely puts a lot more effort defensively, which is why i'd give him the nod over Amare. However, Stat isnt exactly a poor defender, he just has no effort.
- 7,084
- 45
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2007
People are jumping on the Bosh bandwagon cuz he's on Miami huh?!
It's really 1A/B IMO.
Offensively, Bosh aint ever coming close to Stat. That's just me. Amare has far more range, a better midrange game, as well as more of a post game. Bosh? Ehh.
However, Bosh definitely puts a lot more effort defensively, which is why i'd give him the nod over Amare. However, Stat isnt exactly a poor defender, he just has no effort.
It's really 1A/B IMO.
Offensively, Bosh aint ever coming close to Stat. That's just me. Amare has far more range, a better midrange game, as well as more of a post game. Bosh? Ehh.
However, Bosh definitely puts a lot more effort defensively, which is why i'd give him the nod over Amare. However, Stat isnt exactly a poor defender, he just has no effort.
- 3,705
- 666
- Joined
- Jun 25, 2002
So you're judging his defense on 1 game against arguably the best big man in the game? Again, don't get it.
- 3,705
- 666
- Joined
- Jun 25, 2002
So you're judging his defense on 1 game against arguably the best big man in the game? Again, don't get it.
- 3,938
- 11
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2007
All I've seen from Bosh on a consistent basis is him from 15-18 feet. Amare can hit that and he's a lot more aggressive on the offensive end. Both Bosh and Amare don't have great post games so I'm gonna go with the more aggressive player.
- 3,938
- 11
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2007
All I've seen from Bosh on a consistent basis is him from 15-18 feet. Amare can hit that and he's a lot more aggressive on the offensive end. Both Bosh and Amare don't have great post games so I'm gonna go with the more aggressive player.
- 25,496
- 655
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2004
1.Dirk and gasol>>>>both them bums
2.bosh can do everything amare can on offense
2. thats what makes people poor defender..zero effort
- 25,496
- 655
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2004
1.Dirk and gasol>>>>both them bums
2.bosh can do everything amare can on offense
2. thats what makes people poor defender..zero effort
sonoftony
Supporter
- 29,161
- 23,314
- Joined
- Apr 3, 2005
This.^
sonoftony
Supporter
- 29,161
- 23,314
- Joined
- Apr 3, 2005
This.^
- 16,335
- 13
- Joined
- Dec 27, 2002
Amar'e plays on the New York Knicks. It doesn't surprise me one bit that he's put up better numbers than Chris Bosh. So what? That doesn't make him the better player in any way.
If you want to use stats, alright. Bosh has been more efficient, his offensive and defensive ratings are superior and his win share is higher.
Amar'e is a superior athlete that developed a semi-reliable jumpshot. That's why he fits on ridiculous teams that run, run and run some more, and play zero defense. He would look far worse on the Heat than Bosh has.
Stop it.
- 16,335
- 13
- Joined
- Dec 27, 2002
Amar'e plays on the New York Knicks. It doesn't surprise me one bit that he's put up better numbers than Chris Bosh. So what? That doesn't make him the better player in any way.
If you want to use stats, alright. Bosh has been more efficient, his offensive and defensive ratings are superior and his win share is higher.
Amar'e is a superior athlete that developed a semi-reliable jumpshot. That's why he fits on ridiculous teams that run, run and run some more, and play zero defense. He would look far worse on the Heat than Bosh has.
Stop it.
- 5,140
- 12
- Joined
- Apr 6, 2005
the only people who rebound worse than amare are andrea bargnani and his 6 year old niece.
in no universe is amare stoudamire better than chris bosh.
in no universe is amare stoudamire better than chris bosh.
- 5,140
- 12
- Joined
- Apr 6, 2005
the only people who rebound worse than amare are andrea bargnani and his 6 year old niece.
in no universe is amare stoudamire better than chris bosh.
in no universe is amare stoudamire better than chris bosh.
- 3,938
- 11
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2007
Really? Because Amare is playing better than Bosh so far this season. You can talk about roles all you want but Bosh has shown absolutely nothing so far this season while at least Amare has been aggressive offensively. You can talk about new roles all you want but it's about how they're playing and Bosh is playing his new role horribly. Comparing Amare to Bosh is a push, it can go either way, but saying "in no universe" is a huge stretch. Neither have back to the basket games, both aren't great rebounders, both aren't great defenders, both can take it the cup, and both can hit from 15-18 feet. They're pretty much the same player.
- 3,938
- 11
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2007
Really? Because Amare is playing better than Bosh so far this season. You can talk about roles all you want but Bosh has shown absolutely nothing so far this season while at least Amare has been aggressive offensively. You can talk about new roles all you want but it's about how they're playing and Bosh is playing his new role horribly. Comparing Amare to Bosh is a push, it can go either way, but saying "in no universe" is a huge stretch. Neither have back to the basket games, both aren't great rebounders, both aren't great defenders, both can take it the cup, and both can hit from 15-18 feet. They're pretty much the same player.
- 21,151
- 37
- Joined
- Mar 13, 2004
yeah....amare has looked better than bosh, but if they switched spots and Bosh was in NY, I think he'd be putting up similar #'s as the undisputed #1 option. Hypothetically, how do you think Amare would do in Miami?
- 21,151
- 37
- Joined
- Mar 13, 2004
yeah....amare has looked better than bosh, but if they switched spots and Bosh was in NY, I think he'd be putting up similar #'s as the undisputed #1 option. Hypothetically, how do you think Amare would do in Miami?
