Breaking News: Derrick Rose named 2010-2011 MVP

Originally Posted by dland24

Originally Posted by kix4kix

Originally Posted by mgrand15

I respect stats and all but you guys are humans, not computers. You don't need stats to back up every single point in a free flowing game like basketball. Using basketball knowledge, how does that Chicago Bull team score more than 85 points a game without Rose? Boozer and Deng would have to turn into playmakers. CJ Watson is probably the third option. We're not computers and the MVP isn't determined by an equation. Bulls with an average PG turn into a mediocre but scrappy team. Heat with an average SF are still contenders. Yeah, Lebron had the best stats but I don't see how that doesn't factor into your decisions at all. Is it really blasphemy to make points using basketball knowledge?
Don't use that talk on here, cats love talking about stats I didn't even know existed, let alone used to determine the value of a basketball player. I love stats as much as the next man, but when it is the crux of an argument
tired.gif
.Sometimes I don't need to see the stat line to know a value of a given player, I just need eyes.
When you have a group of players who are extremely close in terms of their value to their teams, what should you use to compare them then?

You say it shouldnt be used as the crux of an argument.  But what should then?  Your eyes?  Isnt the point of arguing to provide some sort of evidence or basis of your argument?  When you are comparing two (or three) players to each other, if you cant use stats to compare, what can you use?

I am seriously asking this.  Id love a response.
Game bruh, seriously. For instance, alot of these guys in the pro were statistically unimpressive in college/Europe, Take Marvin Williams, and Brandon Jennings respectively- If they were drafted on college production like Sheldon Williams who was perhaps the greatest reach in NBA draft history than they would have never been drafted as high as they were. 
Also stats rely so much on playing time, and rosters. For instance, before Al Jefferson was traded, if one based off stats alone would they not say Jefferson > Love?

Stats are nice to support an argument, but the first and foremost thing should be their game, and anyone who has hooped, knows damn well 80% of what goes on does not show up in the boxscore. It's really quite simple, can one play or not? If they are close enough to where stats are needed, it is probably subjective at that point anyway......

"Lies, damned lies, and statistics
 
Originally Posted by dland24

Originally Posted by kix4kix

Originally Posted by mgrand15

I respect stats and all but you guys are humans, not computers. You don't need stats to back up every single point in a free flowing game like basketball. Using basketball knowledge, how does that Chicago Bull team score more than 85 points a game without Rose? Boozer and Deng would have to turn into playmakers. CJ Watson is probably the third option. We're not computers and the MVP isn't determined by an equation. Bulls with an average PG turn into a mediocre but scrappy team. Heat with an average SF are still contenders. Yeah, Lebron had the best stats but I don't see how that doesn't factor into your decisions at all. Is it really blasphemy to make points using basketball knowledge?
Don't use that talk on here, cats love talking about stats I didn't even know existed, let alone used to determine the value of a basketball player. I love stats as much as the next man, but when it is the crux of an argument
tired.gif
.Sometimes I don't need to see the stat line to know a value of a given player, I just need eyes.
When you have a group of players who are extremely close in terms of their value to their teams, what should you use to compare them then?

You say it shouldnt be used as the crux of an argument.  But what should then?  Your eyes?  Isnt the point of arguing to provide some sort of evidence or basis of your argument?  When you are comparing two (or three) players to each other, if you cant use stats to compare, what can you use?

I am seriously asking this.  Id love a response.
Game bruh, seriously. For instance, alot of these guys in the pro were statistically unimpressive in college/Europe, Take Marvin Williams, and Brandon Jennings respectively- If they were drafted on college production like Sheldon Williams who was perhaps the greatest reach in NBA draft history than they would have never been drafted as high as they were. 
Also stats rely so much on playing time, and rosters. For instance, before Al Jefferson was traded, if one based off stats alone would they not say Jefferson > Love?

Stats are nice to support an argument, but the first and foremost thing should be their game, and anyone who has hooped, knows damn well 80% of what goes on does not show up in the boxscore. It's really quite simple, can one play or not? If they are close enough to where stats are needed, it is probably subjective at that point anyway......

"Lies, damned lies, and statistics
 
The years lebron won it was he not the Best Player on the Best Team in the league?

This year the Bulls were the Best Team and their Best Player is Rose.

whatever...
 
The years lebron won it was he not the Best Player on the Best Team in the league?

This year the Bulls were the Best Team and their Best Player is Rose.

whatever...
 
Originally Posted by kix4kix

Is it too late to vote for Zach Randolph?


i seriously hope that was sarcasm...  



you guys would start a team with rose over lebron then?
since hes better and more "valuable"

after watching Lebron play this season....yes.
 
Originally Posted by kix4kix

Is it too late to vote for Zach Randolph?


i seriously hope that was sarcasm...  



you guys would start a team with rose over lebron then?
since hes better and more "valuable"

after watching Lebron play this season....yes.
 
^ what's even more stupid is your ability to quote.....  


i'd want a guy that knows how to finish, is the 1st option when the game is on the line, and that person wants the ball in that situation...
 
^ what's even more stupid is your ability to quote.....  


i'd want a guy that knows how to finish, is the 1st option when the game is on the line, and that person wants the ball in that situation...
 
^yea, hard to navigate this site on an iPad. sorry about that...

Over LeBron? Really?
laugh.gif
laugh.gif
laugh.gif
laugh.gif

Do you remember the marketing plans this team concocted to get that guy over here? The boxes sent to his house? He's the best player in the world, hands down. DRose isn't even the best PG in the league.


Derrick Rose went from being underrated to overrated in about 5 weeks...
 
^yea, hard to navigate this site on an iPad. sorry about that...

Over LeBron? Really?
laugh.gif
laugh.gif
laugh.gif
laugh.gif

Do you remember the marketing plans this team concocted to get that guy over here? The boxes sent to his house? He's the best player in the world, hands down. DRose isn't even the best PG in the league.


Derrick Rose went from being underrated to overrated in about 5 weeks...
 
Yea and Derrick Rose didn't want him. He knew what the world knew later. That Lebron is not the 1st option when it comes to clutch basketball.
 
Yea and Derrick Rose didn't want him. He knew what the world knew later. That Lebron is not the 1st option when it comes to clutch basketball.
 
im a lebron fan and if u ask me i think overall lebron is a better player and i would start him before rose, with that said u cant say lebron got robbed
cuz rose had a great year his stats are there ,, you cant be mad its usually the first place team that gets mvp
 
im a lebron fan and if u ask me i think overall lebron is a better player and i would start him before rose, with that said u cant say lebron got robbed
cuz rose had a great year his stats are there ,, you cant be mad its usually the first place team that gets mvp
 
Bron gettin robbed for MVP


Listen champ, Lebron had his chance to have his name in the MVP award running and be the 1st choice but true to form he choked it away by missing all those clutch shots down the stretch for his team in key games........mostly on national TV at that. 

[url=http://sports.espn.go.com/chicago/nba/news/story?id=6468133]http://sports.espn.go.com...ba/news/story?id=6468133[/url]


Excellent news!!  At the end of the day all you Lebron, Kobe, Dwight and Zach Randolph (lol) fans are going to have to put your MVP posters back in the closet to be saved for another year.  As it stands right now Derrick Rose is the MVP this year and for good reason.  So all you dudes can keep writing paragraphs and essays till your little hearts are content trying to convince people otherwise but it will be all for nothing. 
 
Bron gettin robbed for MVP


Listen champ, Lebron had his chance to have his name in the MVP award running and be the 1st choice but true to form he choked it away by missing all those clutch shots down the stretch for his team in key games........mostly on national TV at that. 

[url=http://sports.espn.go.com/chicago/nba/news/story?id=6468133]http://sports.espn.go.com...ba/news/story?id=6468133[/url]


Excellent news!!  At the end of the day all you Lebron, Kobe, Dwight and Zach Randolph (lol) fans are going to have to put your MVP posters back in the closet to be saved for another year.  As it stands right now Derrick Rose is the MVP this year and for good reason.  So all you dudes can keep writing paragraphs and essays till your little hearts are content trying to convince people otherwise but it will be all for nothing. 
 
Back
Top Bottom