- 4,104
- 12
Originally Posted by GrimlocK
Okay so something else just dawned on me, maybe it's been stated already. When Ben met up with Widmore in his bedroom (haha...+#$%...it may be) they stated that each other can't return to the island. Could that mean that Widmore turned the wheel? And I wondered if Alpert was the original one who could talk to Jacob but through certain events he fell out of favor and Ben took counsel role, then it was taken away from him by Locke.
That's been speculated (and is probably true, IMO). Especially now that we know a young Widmore was on the island. But, it hasn't been officiallyconfirmed.
I don't think Alpert ever fell out with Jacob, I wouldn't be surprised if they was father and son, brothers, or possibly the same person (stuck indifferent time loops).