- 33,998
- 29,379
Good point bringing up boxing. Half that sport needs translators and they're doing fine.
yah because nobody ever complains about boxing.
boxing is a great place.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Good point bringing up boxing. Half that sport needs translators and they're doing fine.
I wouldn't say it's doing just fine. All the best boxers in the world speak English. Hell, even all the most popular MMA fighters speak English as well.
"obvious truth?" the obvious truth is rooted in xenophobia? baseball's marketability has nothing to do with shohei needing an interpreter
baseball's declining viewership is connected to many things, including, the deadball era, lower run production and long games during an era in which society has so many other forms of entertainment to engage with. matter of fact, you could argue that shohei's bat makes the MLB more watchable.
saying that a person needs to speak english so that the MLB is more watchable is akin to white people going into a mexican or chinese restaurant and then telling the workers to speak english.
i'd watch manny pacquiao's pre- and post-fight pressers during his prime and barely understand a word he said.. but boxing wasn't hurting for an audience.
The world has caught up, but USA is still a powerhouse. Even in 04, that wasn't a matter of Team USA sending its best and just ending up with bronze. Iverson & Duncan were the only 2 from the original squad that had been playing together. The whole rest of the roster was filled in last minute, which is similar to 2021.what about 04? and world games? 02, 06? team usa hasnt just been a super power since 92, these was some trash in there too.
If I was playing basketball in the Philippines and was big star
and someone told me;
"man you'd be a bigger star if you learn Tagalog. kinda sucks the biggest star in the PBA can't speak Tagalog. "
I would not recoil in horror and accuse them of anti canadian immigrant xenophobia.
and neither would anyone in this thread. because it's pretty self evident.
I think it's a copout to say the rest of the world has caught up. These US teams aren't playing up to their own potential. None of these teams they've been losing to have anywhere close to the same caliber of individual talent
If I was playing basketball in the Philippines and was big star
and someone told me;
"man you'd be a bigger star if you learn Tagalog. kinda sucks the biggest star in the PBA can't speak Tagalog. "
I would not recoil in horror and accuse them of anti canadian immigrant xenophobia.
and neither would anyone in this thread. because it's pretty self evident.
This language thing is another instance where comparing regular people to pro athletes is apples to oranges. Most regular people aren’t asked to deal with the media as part of their jobs the way pro athletes are, especially star players.
Ohtani can speak some English and probably does on a day-to-day basis when dealing with his teammates and coaches, etc. But he uses an interpreter for interviews and press conferences and doing so makes perfect sense. Actually makes the process easier and more efficient for all involved.
In Canada, especially where im from, it's a huge advantage in many jobs to be bilingual.
people will tell you, you want to get this job, or make more money learn French.
my mom tried her damndest to learn french for a promotion. could never quite reach work level fluency.
she did not recoil in horror and say "uh this is xenophobic against immigrants from non romance language speaking countries".
Canada is a bilingual country it's good for your career to know one of or both French and english.
its not xenophobic to state this reality.
This language thing is another instance where comparing regular people to pro athletes is apples to oranges. Most regular people aren’t asked to deal with the media as part of their jobs the way pro athletes are, especially star players.
Ohtani can speak some English and probably does on a day-to-day basis when dealing with his teammates and coaches, etc. But he uses an interpreter for interviews and press conferences and doing so makes perfect sense. Actually makes the process easier and more efficient for all involved.
Yea I think that's a copout. KD got blocked by thybulle on a play where he went 1 on 5. Doesn't take 10+ years to know you should pass the ball in that situation.You're right. We're head and shoulders above the rest of the talent.
But these teams have been playing together for 10+ years. Hell, most of them have been consistently playing together since they were kids. There's an element of chemistry they have, which our guys don't.
We basically put together a team in less than 2 weeks, while teams like Nigeria and Australia have been practicing since June. Of course we're going to look out of sync.
You from Montreal? I got some fam out in Jean Talon.
of course it makes sense personally for him to use an interpreter.
I don't think anyone should not use an interpreter if they aren't comfortable expressing themselves accurately in the native language.
I def would use an interpreter if I was in another country.
im speaking about the interests of baseball.
which in this case happen to conflict with what may be best for ohtani personally.
Didn't Shaq mention in his HoF speech of Yao Ming doing something similar? Homie knew how to speak some English, while everyone outside his teammates assumed he didn't.
English is an official language of the Philippines doe.
I can’t speak to the xenophobia of another country but in America telling an Asian man “dude speak English” at the height of Asian hate is wild.
Yeah. I still don’t think it would make a big difference from a marketability standpoint. The same kind of people that would be put off by someone using an interpreter aren’t going to respond much better to hearing someone speaking heavily accented English, IMO.