- 37,455
- 12,894
We all know Willis is no #1 starter anymore.... But is he a decent bullpen arm? no one has tried that, and you can't really deny if he can get it going, he could be a good bullpen addition.
We need bullpen arms.... As important as we need starters... Do I think we need Willis so much that it jeopardizes Cliff Lee or Crawford if we go after him? No, don't be ridiculous.
But do I feel Willis has something left? Yes.. He's a lefty who can still throw 90+.. Showed flashes of himself in 2010 albeit for a few starts, but a completely different role may make it a constant...
Yankees used to be king of "project" players.... And this is a project....
You sign Willis for cheap and looking at his current prospects he would take anything... So you know it is not a huge financial risk..You will know if it doesn't work, and if it doesn't get rid of him.....
You get him into better shape, and tweak his mechanics (best case scenario it clicks, worst case scenario it doesn't work out and less than a mil was wasted on trying an idea)
Did we not just have a 10-10 starter with a 5+ ERA making $11M to be a #4 last off-season... That is a huge risk... This is hardly a risk compared to that..
As for A.J. we spent all year complaining about him... No one says get rid of him. If we get Cliff Lee.. He certainly isn't #1 or #2.. So already he is demoted to #3 as compared to the role we signed him to do... Then we have 2 guys who had much better seasons (Pettitte if he comes back, and Hughes)... Also as a 5th starter, you hardly have any pressure on you. Pressure is something A.J. seems to not take too well.. As a 5th starter if you give us 5-1/3 of good innings we'll take it... As a number 2 starter you are expected to give 7... He was the number 2 starter up until August... Then was demoted to 4th starter, and finally by September he was the #5 starter.. And a #4 in the playoffs...
As for Gardener what do we use him for? Speed and small ball that's it.... He really hasn't got anything else.. With Crawford he isn't a better fielder than any of the OF we have... But it seems Girardi wants him in the lineup no matter what, so you put him at the DH role... Not all players are good DH's because when your only job is to hit, and that is not going well, you fall apart.. and Swisher definitely isn't... Swisher plays with so much intensity only letting him get at bats would be a potential land mind if he is not doing well... Putting him out there to field allows him more concentration on baseball as a whole, instead of just hitting...
In a best case scenario world, Montero is ready for the majors as a starting catcher. Posada is going to start regardless leaves us with either C or DH, and I find it unlikely for Girardi to not put him at Catcher considering he did it for half the games in 2010 when he is barely a functional catcher anymore..... But I am going on what is likely and what is most likely is he plays Catcher half the season.. I'd rather Gardener be a bench player, but taking into account past history, what is going on, who Girardi is likely to start at Catcher, Montero doesn't start very often.. So that leaves us with either Thames or Gardener... Reason I take Gardener is we need a person in the lineup who will play small ball, and Gardener can do that..
We need bullpen arms.... As important as we need starters... Do I think we need Willis so much that it jeopardizes Cliff Lee or Crawford if we go after him? No, don't be ridiculous.
But do I feel Willis has something left? Yes.. He's a lefty who can still throw 90+.. Showed flashes of himself in 2010 albeit for a few starts, but a completely different role may make it a constant...
Yankees used to be king of "project" players.... And this is a project....
You sign Willis for cheap and looking at his current prospects he would take anything... So you know it is not a huge financial risk..You will know if it doesn't work, and if it doesn't get rid of him.....
You get him into better shape, and tweak his mechanics (best case scenario it clicks, worst case scenario it doesn't work out and less than a mil was wasted on trying an idea)
Did we not just have a 10-10 starter with a 5+ ERA making $11M to be a #4 last off-season... That is a huge risk... This is hardly a risk compared to that..
As for A.J. we spent all year complaining about him... No one says get rid of him. If we get Cliff Lee.. He certainly isn't #1 or #2.. So already he is demoted to #3 as compared to the role we signed him to do... Then we have 2 guys who had much better seasons (Pettitte if he comes back, and Hughes)... Also as a 5th starter, you hardly have any pressure on you. Pressure is something A.J. seems to not take too well.. As a 5th starter if you give us 5-1/3 of good innings we'll take it... As a number 2 starter you are expected to give 7... He was the number 2 starter up until August... Then was demoted to 4th starter, and finally by September he was the #5 starter.. And a #4 in the playoffs...
As for Gardener what do we use him for? Speed and small ball that's it.... He really hasn't got anything else.. With Crawford he isn't a better fielder than any of the OF we have... But it seems Girardi wants him in the lineup no matter what, so you put him at the DH role... Not all players are good DH's because when your only job is to hit, and that is not going well, you fall apart.. and Swisher definitely isn't... Swisher plays with so much intensity only letting him get at bats would be a potential land mind if he is not doing well... Putting him out there to field allows him more concentration on baseball as a whole, instead of just hitting...
In a best case scenario world, Montero is ready for the majors as a starting catcher. Posada is going to start regardless leaves us with either C or DH, and I find it unlikely for Girardi to not put him at Catcher considering he did it for half the games in 2010 when he is barely a functional catcher anymore..... But I am going on what is likely and what is most likely is he plays Catcher half the season.. I'd rather Gardener be a bench player, but taking into account past history, what is going on, who Girardi is likely to start at Catcher, Montero doesn't start very often.. So that leaves us with either Thames or Gardener... Reason I take Gardener is we need a person in the lineup who will play small ball, and Gardener can do that..