- 26,812
- 38,428
In terms of substance I definitely think Kaine washed Pence throughout most of the debate. He hammered him with a lot of issues he struggled to defend like you said. Pence trying to defend stop and frisk and talking about "we need to stop talking about systemic bias" was painful to watch.I get it, but it's still ridiculous to me how people rely more on temperament than the actual stance of the two candidates.
I sat there and listened to Pence say almost nothing for a 1.5 hours. He couldn't defend much and in most cases didn't even attempt to do so. He just stuck to a few specific talking points. That and his inability to admit that there is systemic bias in the police department while at the same time saying we need huge criminal justice reform in response to the statistics proving so I just can't get past.
Kaine started out nervous. He didn't seem comfortable, and looked unsure of himself, but eventually I thought he seemed to get things together.
Pence definitely had the better temperament, but he said nothing, and when he was actually answering questions I strongly disagreed with him.
So what do we base the winner of a debate on? It seems everyone has a different standard. I thought Kaine won handily, but I see there's a large group of people who think Pence did a great job.
But substance is very subjective. So I don't think that's the only element that determines a victor of the debate. People who support Hillary are gonna favor Kaine and Trump supporters are gonna favor Pence on substance. So I think it's better to have 2 kinds of victors. Substance is subjective so I also look at the parts of debating that don't involve injecting my personal bias into it. Which leaves composure, delivery, ...
Pence was calm, calculated and looked like he'd done a hundred debates before throughout the whole thing. His delivery was also a lot better than Kaine, which helped mask his empty answers and dancing around topics. Kaine appeared quite nervous and the interrupting certainly didn't help that.
At some points he really nailed his delivery but he also appeared shaky in other instances.
Pence definitely outshined Kaine in that regard, so I would say Pence came out as the better debater
Last edited: