That's your closure. Those are the only two options. Also I'm pretty sure paulie was a rat at the end
Right, but after all that, we're left to GUESS if he was or not?And with what proof? Not once do you see him talk to an agent, ever, in the show.
And don't bring up AJ, please, don't. His storyline almost made me tear my TV out of the wall. Swear to God I have no idea what the hell they were thinking with that @#$%. Was the writer strike happening at that time?
As for Tony, you have read the explanation, haven't you? What the fade to black meant.Simmons spoke on it a while back.