Justified is complicated. It'd kinda be like calling
Deadwood a cop show...which Olyphant was a sheriff on too.
That Southern gothic noir side of it is so far and away the main thing to take from
Justified. And even then...the show's kinda up and down?
The first season was a pretty regular cable procedural. It could've been on USA channel. The 2nd season though....that was pretty damn great. That put it way up in the conversation and basically cemented it as something I gotta check in on. But it's settled back now into good, clever, charming TV. It's like
The Closer, but better written and less corny. And I don't think it's ever really gonna get back to that season 2 level for more than a couple eps a season.
Justified has great characters. Boyd, Ava, Raylan, his parents, his boss... But outside of season 2, most of the time, the cop part of it is pretty regular. And normally I can't stick with those...cop procedural type of shows. Like
Bones...
Castle...
SVU. But this is a much better version of that. And they're always trying to stay a step ahead of all the cliches that go with those shows.
But
Southland is something more. It doesn't rely on it's main characters being charming. If anything it relies on breaking them down as realistically as possible and lifting up the plain ugliness and...I dunno...brutality of the streets around them to tell it's story. And the understated way that they escalate things on this show is so impressive. It'd be easy for this to be cable's Law & Order: SVU, but it's so much more than that.
And they show, they don't tell. They don't assume their audience is stupid or not paying attention. It's almost a documentary like that. It's the new NYPD: Blue. It's not on
The Wire or
The Shield's level, but there are moments...trust...where it's right there.