Amazingly, we have the same exact confounding problem we had a year ago: There are three MVPs, but only one can win each year. Once again, Giannis Antetokounmpo, Joel Embiid and Nikola Jokić are each having seasons that, historically, are usually good enough to win somebody an MVP trophy.
Consider that of the top-13 all-time seasons in PER since individual turnovers began being tracked in 1977-78, there have been seven such instances by these three gentlemen in the past four seasons. Last season, Embiid’s mark was bested by only eight individual seasons in the 44 campaigns between 1977-78 and 2020-21 … but it was topped by Jokić’s all-time record of 32.8 and Antetokoumpo’s 32.1 in 2021-22.
It’s really been an amazing stretch of history. Before we start splitting hairs between who’s better and starting nasty fights between Nuggets, Bucks and Sixers fans, let’s take a moment to let it sink in:
These are the three best players in the league right now by a significant margin, according to most advanced stats and the two things between my ears and above my nose. To use a couple of the nerdier metrics out there, DARKO has a wide gap between these three and a next tier of 10 clustered players that include the other familiar faces you might bring up in this argument, while LEBRON has them first, second and fourth. As noted in the chart above, they are first, third and fifth by PER and first, second and fourth by BPM.
While Jokić is still first in every one of these metrics, his lead has tightened — he even briefly lost his PER lead to Embiid and now leads by a 10th of a point. Additionally, the narrative on this award has unquestionably shifted. Jokić has maybe not quite been as dominant as he was the first half of the season, and perhaps of equal importance, the Nuggets no longer have more wins than the Bucks or Sixers.
As long as the Nuggets were ahead of those two in the standings, with Jokić their lone All-Star, he had a slam dunk prima facie case. The narrative was all his. (I’m aware James Harden didn’t make it this year for Philly. But literally nobody on the Nuggets has ever played in the game even once except DeAndre Jordan, who may or may not still be on the team, I haven’t really checked in a while.)
Now it gets interesting. Jokić still leads in the advanced stats and has the added advantage of having played more games and minutes than the other two, but there is a fair question of whether those stats take his defense into enough account.
There is also the issue of his offensive role. While Jokić’s 27 percent usage is notable for a center, it pales next to Embiid and Giannis … and Kyle Kuzma and Keldon Johnson and 32 other players. His efficiency in those possessions is utterly ridiculous (70.3 percent true shooting! That can’t be real! He shoots 62 percent from floater range!), but there are times you wish he was more of a pig.
Like, please shoot this?
Of course, Jokić is also the easiest teammate to play with on the planet, a mismatch in virtually any one-on-one matchup and someone who combines that with all-time great brilliance as a passer. Even his boring plays are amazing. Here, have a post entry:
Antetokounmpo has emerged back into the race as the Bucks have taken over the league’s top record, His undeniability as a two-way force on the league’s title favorite, and the creeping feeling that he should have more than two MVPs by this point, both likely factor into his candidacy.
Relative to Jokić, Antetokounmpo leads the league in usage rate, but it’s the opposite issues if you’re nit-picking: There are times you wish he’d pull back on the throttle. He still takes nearly five 3s per 100 possessions and mostly bricks them (28.8 percent), and his unsustainably high conversion rate on midrange 2s last season has fallen back to its historic range in the mid-30s. As a result, he’s actually having his least-efficient season in terms of both true shooting and PER since 2017-18.
On the other hand, his Bucks are possibly the closest thing we have to a dominant team right now, and he’s clearly the engine. A strong closing push that leaves the Bucks as the top overall seed will leave him with a strong case for his third trophy.
That said, how about Embiid? It would be a pretty tough pill to swallow if he very narrowly loses out on MVP to Jokić for a third straight year. Embiid’s stretch run this season has been jaw-droppingly awesome; he’s averaging a point a minute since the All-Star break and made at least half his shots in all 13 of those games, while also earning an absurdly ridiculous 13 free-throw attempts per game and being cash money (85.5 percent) from the stripe. As a scorer, Embiid doesn’t quite match Jokić’s efficiency but does it with far greater frequency.
He can still have his foibles — while Sixers fans have made a new sport out of Zaprudering Jokić’s defensive failings (hey, it’s still better than pickleball), Embiid’s own defensive effort can fluctuate sharply from play to play. He’s also still prone to turnovers on double-teams, although he’s cut those since the break too.
In a close race, however, you wonder if sentiment will be strongly on his side. These three awesome players are going to have five MVP awards between them at the end of this season; Jokić and Giannis will have at least two, and it seems a bit bizarre in comparison that Embiid will have zero of them.
How to choose? Good luck with that. I’m letting the season play out before I stan for any of these three, but this is not the cakewalk to a Jokić three-peat that it seemed to be in February.