I didn't say Gotze would excel as a false 9, I said Javi should excel playing CB. He's played the position successfully at Athletic Bilbao & for the national team. Why go out & buy another CB when you have resources available on your team?
I never said Gotze would excel as a false 9, I said I liked the idea but after thinking about it more, I think he should do well. I think that's what Pep had envisioned all along when they xferred him to Bayern.
Gotze has the same attacking ability as Messi. Plus he's played the false 9 role for the German national team & did fairly well (albeit for 3-4 games). He did great his first time out front against Kazakhstan back in March.
Mandzukic would see the bench, but Gotze, Ribery, Muller being supported by Kroos, Schweinsteiger, & possibly Thiago would be nice. It would also be similar to the style Pep played at Barca...
People making blanket statements without knowing these guys have already played well in those roles is down right silly. I guess it's hard to see when your too busy to put the controllers down...
It's all good though...Cheers.