- 146,734
- 178,683
Speaking of NIL
OFFICIAL 2022-2023 COLLEGE FOOTBALL THREAD
- Thread in 'Sports & Training' Thread starter Started by Bobby Layne,
- Start date
- Status
- 146,734
- 178,683
There's straight up at least 5 backs I'd take over Bijan for this
The DeVonta Smith erasure is criminal too, what other WR won a Heisman in that timespan??
Also Sunshine over Burrow is an interesting choice...
- 24,170
- 19,455
There's straight up at least 5 backs I'd take over Bijan for this
The DeVonta Smith erasure is criminal too, what other WR won a Heisman in that timespan??
Also Sunshine over Burrow is an interesting choice...
The only thing I can see with Lawrence over Joe was Lawrence was a gamer from the start. People always forget Joes first year at LSU was pretty bad. So it depends if you’re taking an all time season over one of the better careers we’ve seen.
aepps20
Supporter
- 42,507
- 90,675
- 12,554
- 5,657
Lawrence had three years of production and better raw physical tools. I don’t disagree with that choice.
I’d have Saquon over Bijan, but other than that, that list is fine.
I’d have Saquon over Bijan, but other than that, that list is fine.
- 33,424
- 12,556
- 33,424
- 12,556
Chase over Devonta? Devonta kinda has him beat in every way.
- 146,734
- 178,683
Henry, Saquon, CMC, Zeke and Taylor were all more dominant guys during their times.
DeVonta is the biggest snub though especially with Waddle there.
Can understand Sunshine but I'd still have Burrow and Watson ahead of him.
- 12,554
- 5,657
Chase has better physical tools, and Devonta realistically probably walks around at like 160.
Durability was a legit concern for DeVonta as a prospect.
dacomeup
Supporter
- 26,524
- 37,414
Same thing at Miami
dacomeup
Supporter
- 26,524
- 37,414
Chase was the better player the moment he walked on campus and Devonta was the third best guy in his own class. Imagine Ja’Marr Chase playing a senior year of football at LSU. He was a Top 5 receiver in the NFL and headed to a Super Bowl that year
… his rookie year
- 33,424
- 12,556
But Devonta played more games than him…
- 33,424
- 12,556
You’re recused from thisChase was the better player the moment he walked on campus and Devonta was the third best guy in his own class. Imagine Ja’Marr Chase playing a senior year of football at LSU. He was a Top 5 receiver in the NFL and headed to a Super Bowl that year
- 33,424
- 12,556
dacomeup
Supporter
- 26,524
- 37,414
PFF is likely going by their highest rated season using their metrics. They’re not a stay aggregator
- 12,554
- 5,657
- 33,424
- 12,556
Yes I get that. I’m saying in response to the question about Devonta’s durability and in comparison to Jamar’s, I believe Devonta thus far has been the more durable player. I don’t think he missed a game due to injury in college. Jamar did. Jamar has also dealt with injuries in the NFL.PFF is likely going by their highest rated season using their metrics. They’re not a stay aggregator
But yes I get PFF probably goes off their own rating system.
- 33,424
- 12,556
- 7,307
- 1,984
I haven’t seen anything about him indicating otherwise. But other fan bases always seem to have a firmer grasp on A&M athletics than any of our reporters do, so what are you hearing?
Was it because he parked illegally and got a boot on his car?
dacomeup
Supporter
- 26,524
- 37,414
I missed this
. I love Josh Pate but whew that’s some spin on the Baker and Kyler situations with Kliff
- 33,424
- 12,556
Nothing solid. Just heard multiple people from different teams speculate on him. Was wondering why.
- 12,554
- 5,657
aepps20
Supporter
- 42,507
- 90,675
Until it’s opened.
- 6,136
- 981
- 24,170
- 19,455
MVP
Billy isn’t really going to go with Mertz and Miller as the only two QBs is he?- Status
