- Dec 8, 1999
- 7,420
- 29,448
Thanks.
I guess my remaining question is who or what decides what is constituted as an “insult”?
A joke reference to another thread or something related to a specific user in any manner, even in friendly banter, surely shouldn’t be seen as an insult?
I had a post deleted for referencing a sauce from a specific restaurant, I presume it was assumed by the mod that deleted it that it was associated with a specific NTer.
Even if it was, when did any sort of reference to another NTer immediately constitute a post deletion and categorized as an “insult”, as my notification for deletion explained? If that was the case, the forum would be scrubbed of a likely 5-10% of its overall posts.
So again, I ask, why is this thread in particular so heavily policed?
I should add that if you think this conversation should be taken to PM, I’m fine with that. I’m legitimately curious on why this thread in specific is having this issue. I don’t think I’ve ever seen it on NT before, definitely not to this degree.
You’re welcome to PM me, but I think there actually is pretty widespread understanding on this point and users just want to get away with the “casual” roasts.
It’s not “friendly banter” and we don’t want it taking over the thread.
We want the focus in each thread to be on that thread’s topic. Sometimes, things get off track and we need to perform mass post deletions. Unfortunately, that‘s been happening here a lot lately. Maybe that’s because people are bored and there isn’t much new happening with the product line - I don’t know - but if anyone is bored by the thread’s core subject matter, that’s cause to visit another thread, not to change the focus of this one.
If you want to disagree with someone’s hot takes, fine, but if it rises to the level of insult that’s not - and has never been - permissible under our rules, and I’d advise users to use the report and ignore tools to clean up the mess rather than attempt to practice “vigilante justice,” which only spreads the mess around.