- 33,521
- 27,219
Again really wish it was just called the player of the year award part of the constant debate comes from arguing the semantics of “most valuable” and what that means
Player of the year is much clearer. Just simply who’s had the best season.
I feel like most would agree the best players in football this year have been CMC, Hill, Garrett maybe forgetting one other but because we have to go “but are they really that valuable cause of they position” we have to shoe horn QBs into the convo by default despite none of them this year having a year that anyone would say they where the best player in football this year.
Player of the year is much clearer. Just simply who’s had the best season.
I feel like most would agree the best players in football this year have been CMC, Hill, Garrett maybe forgetting one other but because we have to go “but are they really that valuable cause of they position” we have to shoe horn QBs into the convo by default despite none of them this year having a year that anyone would say they where the best player in football this year.
Last edited: