...So, you really think the recent XIs deserve to bear their names? ...You think having an icy sole is worth a botched shape, horrible plastic materials, etc.
That's your decision to make. But, understand that there's going to be a vocal (now) minority who disagree.
Nike could not have gotten away with releasing these versions of the Retros 15 years ago - because the only people who cared to even buy them were discerning aficionados who held the brand and shoes to the same high standard they created for themselves the first time around.
If you hear a terrible song with a catchy melody once, you'll say, "this sucks." But, if you are subjected to it over and over, you'll eventually starting humming it and finding yourself kind of liking it. It's a coping mechanism.
Through savvy marketing, Nike has been able to expand the pool of customers to a much less discerning crowd.
If it gets to the point that I can't wear my OGs or retros that pass muster, then I'll just wear something else before I succumb and just take an inferior product.
I have hundreds of Dunks and AF1s, not to mention plenty of 1985 AJ1s - those joints are indestructible. I already have more shoes than I'll ever wear. So, no need to accept anything less. If all 95/96 and 2001 XIs just disappeared off the face of the earth, I'd just cease wearing XIs. It's not that serious.