The money at HBO may not compare to the payday for a commercial-TV series that hits the syndication jackpot, or to profit participation in a hit feature film, but in a movie universe that grows coarser and more constricted by the second, HBO represents an attractive alternativeâif not a high-prestige life raftâfor big-name talent. âThe line has been blurred,â Sue Naegle told me.
And the alliance between the premier cable network and movie giants such as Mann and Hoffman (the recently canceled Luck), Scorsese (Boardwalk Empire), and now Sorkin (The Social Network, Moneyball) makes for interesting balances of power. Was Sorkinâs confidence in himself or, more likely, in HBO shaken by Naegleâs note about the music? Not in the slightest, he said. âI understood what she meant, and it was a perfectly valid comment.â But, he told me, âI can only write the way I write. Iâm not altering my writing style at all because itâs on HBO. Yes, I am able toâwhen I want toâuse the language of adulthood when people get a little hot under the collar, which wasnât something that I was able to do, say, onThe West Wing.Frankly, I would have loved to be able to do it there. I just would have liked to have seen [Martin Sheenâs President Josiah] Bartlet say âgoddammitâ from time to time, which you canât do. Youâll be able to say â!@+%#$@%+@%+â on network television before youâll be able to take Godâs name in vain on televisionâI promise you.
âSo itâs nice to have that here,â he continued. âItâs nice that HBO is in business with the audience and not with the advertisers. Thereâs a difference. Trying to guess what the [mass] audience wants and then trying to satisfy that is usually a bad recipe for getting something good.â
And the recipe at HBO? âListenâobviously we want people to watch the show,â Sorkin said. âWe want as many people as we can get. But HBO is less interested in how many people are watching than in how much the people who are watching are liking the show. They didnât set up their business model to make writers happy. Itâs just a nice unintended consequence.â