- 281
- 43
or the ''take it to the ____ thread''
this Thread about nothing thread is killing da whole vibe in general...
- Status
- 6,376
- 433
If you're browsing for topics you're already browsing for things that interest you. That same principle applies when you're browsing for posts to reply to in tan.
Why should we have to sift through 4 pages of spam to find thread worthy posts?
What will that prove?
I think the TAN has it's place for certain stuff like quick thoughts that pop into your head, but it moves so fast, nothing can be discussed.
It proves that you actually want thread worthy topics instead of complaining and expecting them to fall into your lap.
"It moves too fast," I keep seeing this phrase as if it means something.
Define moves too fast, so I understand what you mean.
Thread moving fast = pages accumulated faster then u can read & write a indepth response to, thus hurting overall
Conversation of said topic for da sake of "keeping up wit da thread"
The posts in that thread dont need or deserve an in depth response though.
This all boils down to a "you" problem and not a "board" problem. It comes back to you being bored and feel like theres interesting topics that you arent capable of participating in.
Some big game threads move "too fast" for in depth responses, should they be closed? Should there be no Super Bowl thread?
- 42,382
- 44,284
How are you going to say people that post in TAN are too lazy to make a topic when its pretty much the same steps? Technically, its more steps.
TAN post:
1. Log on to NT
2. Go to general.
3. Find and Click on TAN
4. Scroll to the bottom
5. Insert message.
Making a new thread.
1. Log on to NT
2. Go to General
3. Click on Start a New Thread.
4. Insert message.
..and I condensed the TAN posting steps.
TAN post:
1. Log on to NT
2. Go to general.
3. Find and Click on TAN
4. Scroll to the bottom
5. Insert message.
Making a new thread.
1. Log on to NT
2. Go to General
3. Click on Start a New Thread.
4. Insert message.
..and I condensed the TAN posting steps.
- 8,332
- 216
Well, I made an effort to check general at least a few times this weekend and I saw no degradation in thread quality . Heck, I hadn't seen one before this thread's creation and animated existence made me take a look.
Locking that thread would be an unwarranted submission to member(s) that incessantly repeat unsubstantiated claims. Instead, give the persecutor(s) a few days, or even a week, to gather evidence on the alleged offenses. To date, all that's been presented can best be characterized as unwarranted assumptions and sheer misconceptions. It just wouldn't be fair to the frequenters of that thread to lock it in this manner, even if only for a week. The burden of proof has not been met and those accused should remain under the presumption of innocence. The defense pleads for the Niketalk Circuit Court of Huddler to uphold the cherished principles of message board jurisprudence.
Locking that thread would be an unwarranted submission to member(s) that incessantly repeat unsubstantiated claims. Instead, give the persecutor(s) a few days, or even a week, to gather evidence on the alleged offenses. To date, all that's been presented can best be characterized as unwarranted assumptions and sheer misconceptions. It just wouldn't be fair to the frequenters of that thread to lock it in this manner, even if only for a week. The burden of proof has not been met and those accused should remain under the presumption of innocence. The defense pleads for the Niketalk Circuit Court of Huddler to uphold the cherished principles of message board jurisprudence.
Last edited:
- 7,364
- 2,893
Last edited:
- 30,710
- 10,482
Hank for admin position
iamlegend2345
Banned
- 521
- 62
Freaking AWSOME. Would of blown up in general. I wouldn't of know anything about this otherwiseclassic politics....
im so adamant about this issh because on im on NT EVERY DAY, i can TELL its affecting da stagnation of general, and my logic is sound. if you have a garden, and instead of
watering da entire yard, you water only 1 portion constantly, da rest of da garden is gonna wither and die off. when lurkers enter da garden and see that da MAJORITY of da place
is dead and stagnant, is gonna NOT feel inviting or have feelings of wanting to stay....
i haven't been entertained in general, i haven't gotten my mental gymnastics on in here, i didn't learn anything new other then things I MYSELF had to dig for instead of
just browsing general for new stuff.
meanwhile is da thread about nothing.....
i think people would've LOVED to know that samsung was cool enough to give someone a free phone, but because da lazy poster didn't make a thread on it and tossed it in
da abyss, information doesn't travel, synergy isn't realized, and general's garden doesn't get watered again....there's instances of this happening over there CONSTANTLY.
add up how many months that parasite has been sucking da blood of general and its no wonder why general, NT's once mightiest section is sputtering instead of roaring
to life.
shoeking2101
Banned
- 19,728
- 2,456
This Should have been in the thread about nothing.
- 40,141
- 11,080
- 40,141
- 11,080
was posted in the android thread... its own thread would have just been post saying theres an android thread.... & or a fanboy debate
- 7,392
- 29,235
I don't want to argue this on two fronts simultaneously, as I've wasted enough of my Sunday on it as it is, so let me just link this: http://niketalk.com/t/329154/the-thread-about-nothing/40410#post_16338000
The thread has its own actual problems and it's almost been locked on several occasions as it is. If this gives us the opportunity to solve those problems and address a wide array of member concerns, so much the better.
Everyone needs to share these forums. I'd rather we resolve this together than make a hasty all or nothing decision and send a big "screw you" to everyone who disagrees.
There is literally no way to satisfy everyone here. I'd rather at least attempt a reasonable compromise that results in an improved "thread about nothing" than give either side 100% of what they want at the expense of everyone else.
- 10,181
- 3,524
pretty ironic to have a thread about nothing in a section about nothing
makes no sense and I never look in it
makes no sense and I never look in it
- 4,053
- 643
Out of curiosity Meth what do your Sundays consist now that the ******** dont suck ?
- 5,025
- 43
its just a damn thread with only 10 people being the common posters in the thread gaining a bunch of reps for each otheer , loving each other unconditionally
- 70,049
- 24,223
why would anyone do that?
if people agree with what im saying then they're agreeing with da point im trying to make.
i wouldn't buy anything with a jumpman on in because JB decided to hock it out to retailers twitter buzz me about it every 30 seconds.
things stand or fall on their own merit, so if i garnered enough support for my cause based my own credentials and points im bringing up
dont try to sell it short "just cuz im me" thats basically phoning home any sort of opposition toward da thread about nothing and copping a plea.
rusty shackelford
Banned
- 6,437
- 1,177
Some agree with your point, most are here because you're ninjahood.
Ninja you know very well that you have some pull around here.
Don't act like you're new.
- 7,392
- 29,235
They don't?
Anyway, I don't want to detract from the subject at hand, but I'm actually not a fan of that franchise: http://niketalk.com/t/330759/how-is-********-an-appropriate-name-for-a-professional-sports-team/60
Oh, you mean the thread you started?op and last op of other thread hate are fools
http://niketalk.com/t/507542/gnihton-tuoba-daerht-eht
Sounds like you're ready for a one week break yourself.
- 12,264
- 51
My thoughts on the matter.
- 13,868
- 44
not liking this new wave of new NTers....
- 8,332
- 216
I understand you are between a rock and a hard place here but I am suggesting that the animated rhetoric of the accusers be supported by some evidence that isn't rebutted instantly. Then the one-week lock down experiment would have actual cause for implementation. Right now, there isn't any because absolutely nothing has changed. This thread has brought nothing to light and it seems that the only reason for the lock down's origination is out of frustration with the annoying accusations of a few folks. If these folks say that there is too much thread-worthy material being enveloped in one thread, then let's see it. I can't believe the NT staff would bend to such questionable behavior.
Literally everything that could go wrong with the thread in question could go wrong in any mega-long thread. There could be talk about porn and piracy in there as well, and even though I haven't seen it, I wouldn't put it past some of the posters in those threads.Tangents happen all the time. Essentially, every huge thread has the potential to veer off into a "thread about one thing usually and nothing sometimes." Couldn't that be construed as a similar drain on the staff? How would the staff know when the tangents occur? Some of those threads move very fast as well. Is that okay just because someone hasn't made an unsubstantiated big deal about it?
rusty shackelford
Banned
- 6,437
- 1,177
Ninja, I hope for the sake of your argument that the week the TAN is down, is the best week general has ever had.
- 70,049
- 24,223
Originally Posted by cocotaso1
If we get our thread back, guess we gotta be a lot more strict with what happens.
at this fool getting his way though, next time I have an issue ima just make a thread and ***** and moan about it.
even then he wins.
i got a feeling this dust up will be for da entire betterment of Niketalk general.Originally Posted by whyhellothere
when are we forced to abandon our loved one?
where will i be able to post lulz like this
and tell nt that i would like to grow my hair out like this guy just so i could do this?
make a thread about it
Last edited:
mmg
Banned
- 8,261
- 842
I can't wait to see general stay at the same pace, then what is this dude gonna complain about 
- 7,392
- 29,235
Again, that thread was on the verge of being locked a couple of times since the move already.
If I didn't have my doubts about it then I wouldn't be persuaded by the relatively insubstantial arguments brought against it, but the truth of the matter is that quite a few people besides "ninjahood" believe that it's become a drain on forum activity and, to a certain extent, that possibility does exist and is worthy of examination.
The "danger" isn't really a lack of quality topics - we've demonstrated as much already. What can't be denied, however, is that when you have people talking about sports in "the thread about nothing" INSTEAD of the Sports forum, you hurt the Sports forum. When you have people talking about music in "the thread about nothing" INSTEAD of the Music forum, you hurt the Music forum. Rather than users adding diversity to other threads throughout the site, you have one cliquish thread where people just sort of cloister themselves.
I have no real problem with the thread if it serves its intended purpose, but I don't think people understand what that purpose should be. It's for stuff that doesn't belong anywhere else, not for anything and everything.
The reason the "team" threads in Sneaker Showcase work is because they have a clearly defined point. People who like a particular shoe, like the Roshe or the Air Max line, can post about their collections, etc. They aren't sitting in there talking about what's on television, or whether or not the Niners won. You don't have that problem. (You do, however, have people i the "thread about nothing" asking about sneaker releases.)
If the allegation is that the "Thread About Nothing" has become too expansive and permissive, then I think that claim can be supported.
I know, first hand, just how many posts have to be deleted in there to keep it clear and what a drain it's becoming on staff resources. Since it usually involves just one particular group of people, they rarely report problems within the thread - either to cover for friends or because it's quick-moving and they're on to the next thing. However, we have had 2-3 page stretches where 5-12 different people will chime in on something inappropriate, and there can be no denying that it happens more frequently in there than all other large threads combined precisely because there is no set topic.
These are legitimate concerns.
Now, most of these "quality" concerns can't POSSIBLY be substantiated without a trial, so saying, "where's the evidence" is just going to launch a pointless "prove it is" vs. "prove it isn't" debate as seen in every single religion thread.
Rather than engage in something pointless, I'd rather we actually make progress. If we close the thread for a week, this bickering goes away, the "TAN" regulars get to circulate a bit, and hopefully a few perspectives will be changed slightly. If there's no change in behavior/attitude/environment, there's no change in outcomes. This argument just becomes deadlocked and we're stuck with perpetual bitterness and a silly grudge over a forum thread. If it takes ONE WEEK resolve the "quality" argument and redirect the "thread about nothing" in a more productive manner, I think that's a worthy investment.
- Status
