- 18,653
- 9,194
So is everyone a Jew?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
What heritage are we talking about? The fabricated one that claims people from West Africa are the Hebrews of the Bible?
Where is Damascus? Persia? Bethlehem? Ethiopia? These are places mentioned in the Bible. Haven't seen or been made aware of mentions of Timbuktu, Ghana, or Kongo in the biblical texts, which have been used ad nauseam to "prove" the claim above.
Now, expand that map and tell me how far Sudan is from Senegambia.So Kush aint in the Bible anymore?
McGraw Hill aint playing around
Now, expand that map and tell me how far Sudan is from Senegambia.
You keep missing the point that I didn't negate the existence of Black Jews, hence the mention of Ethiopia in my previous comment (could also add Egypt and all the territories around the Horn of Africa).
It is pseudo history because there isn't any evidence to even suggest that this hypothesis might be true.With the original Jews being sent/Migrated all across the world for centuries, is it not possible for them to have mixed and mingled with all kinds of people to have offspring in almost every single ethnic group? How would that be "pseudo history"? You think that they just so happened to have only Migrated to Europe?
One of the main claim of BHIs is that the people taken from West Africa were the real Jews (according to the director of that movie). Where is the evidence that shows that the cultures from current Western Sahara to Angola share cultural commonalities that can be traced back to Middle Eastern Jews?
Demographic and commercial exchanges between Ancient Western/Central African societies and the upper regions of Africa and the middle east were limited due to the difficulty of crossing the Sahara. Ancient folks knew that migration across the desert was a death sentence. That's why Europeans established more permanent links with the continent by sea.What does the distance between Sudan and Senegambia have to do with anything?
Demographic and commercial exchanges between Ancient Western/Central African societies and the upper regions of Africa and the middle east were limited due to the difficulty of crossing the Sahara. Ancient folks knew that migration across the desert was a death sentence. That's why Europeans established more permanent links with the continent by sea.
Most of the communities you listed are modern Jewish communities in Africa, and a number of them converted to Judaism (which is fine and legit) between the 18th and the 20th century (after unproven claims of Jewish ancestry, which is also fine since you can convert to Judaism).
The same Wikipedia article references Jewish communities in Ancient and Medieval Africa (which is of higher interest, since it establishes these people on the continent before the transatlantic slave trade), and you'll see that most of those communities are in:
- the Songhai empire
- Ethiopia, Somalia, Tanzania, Sudan, which makes sense since these are all located in Eastern Africa, and it's a region that has had established trade relationships with the Middle East since the dawn of human civilization.
- and the Maghreb, which also makes sense since Jews have been present in Europe and crossing the Mediterranean sea wasn't a problem.
The ethnic markers of most of the descendants of enslaved Africans place them way south of the Sahara desert, and way west of Sudan. The people they are related to are closer to the coastal areas of the West/Central Africa, and the Jewish presence in those areas at that time was either nonexistent or scarce.
So is everyone a Jew?
Are we the original Christians?Yes everyone is a Jew.
WTF is going on in here?
I was specifically thinking about DNA testing.What are the "ethnic markers" of a group whose names, Gods, culture, religion, language, history, traditions, lineage, and even humanity was stolen from them for hundreds of years?
So is everyone religious?So is everyone a Jew?
This dude said her name should be revealed and ESPN execs buzzed in his ear and he had to quickly apologize and then now he's acting as he said this from a jump.
I was specifically thinking about DNA testing.
But generally speaking about the Americas, it is not exactly true that everything was lost. Africans in Cuba and Brazil have kept some of their cultures and beliefs, which have changed and merged to adapt to their new environment.
I already posted about the book "Exchanging our Country Marks," which reveals the multiple layers of identity of enslaved Africans in the US.
Afropop Worldwide | The Cameroon-Cuba Connection
Special guest Dr. Ivor Miller, back from a 2021 research trip to Cameroon, takes us into the complexities of south Cameroonian spiritual tradition and its connection to the Cuban Abakuá secret society for men, featuring Abakuá-themed music from Cuba, ceremonial music from Cameroon, and Batanga...afropop.org
"High on the Hog" on Netflix covers the ways in which Black Americans preserved some of their culinary heritage. That's actually how I learned that rice was the reason the first Africans in the Carolinas were brought over.
It's also known that the way Americans (well Jack Daniels) distilled whisky is based on a water filtering technique that was brought from West Africa.