If shaq stays healthy i dont see how this trade would not put Cavs over the top..
i don't know about all that... last season the Cavs at their best were very close to a healthy Boston (i know they blew Boston out, but i'm talkingabout whether they'd beat Boston in a playoff series). this trade moves them back behind Boston as well as Orlando in the East.
the Cavs are best when they are running transition and getting open jumpshots in the halfcourt. when they had Z at center, they could spread the floor becauseZ was a midrange threat. now, they will have Shaq clogging the lane and the Cavs won't be able to spread the floor as well. not to mention that they willstill get RAPED by Orlando's (and LAs)'s pick and roll.. Shaq might be a worse pick and roll defender than Z, he can't move his feet at all.
all in all, i think this is all leading up to a disappointing season for the Cavs in 2009 and Lebron's eventual exit after the season.